Does consciousness exist outside the brain reddit. A novel study reports the dynamics of consciousness may be understood by a newly developed conceptual and mathematical framework. “There is no empirically established explanatory framework for understanding how consciousness can exist independently and outside of the brain. Does this not show that memory and records of the 3D are indeed kept outside of the brain? Not by itself. But that implies it's not a function of the brain, and therefore it could continue after we die. A material world is a proposed hypothetical world made of objective matter that exists outside of consciousness/mind. It's often said that we can't explain consciousness, but I don't see why that's so. To address your other statements, it would be more accurate to say we CANNOT reasonably or justifiably have ANY confidence that consciousness can exist without a brain, as there is ZERO evidence of a consciousness functioning without a brain outside of a person's imagination. Brain, or rather mind is a decoder/processor of reality’s data. However, I once heard that there was a Christian (I forgot the name, and the exact wording) who came with the counterargument that even though that might be true, things exist because everything exists within God's consciousness. One of the more uncomfortable ideas is that consciousness is just an accidental by-product, rather than the main purpose of the brain. My thoughts on this: if consciousness could exist outside of a brain then it wouldn't have to be bound to memory (because memory is bound to the brain), but since it is (we can not remember the time before we were born), I assume that the consciousness can not exist outside of a brain. No consciousness, no perception of having a body at all. ’ Modern neuroscientific approaches suggest consciousness and matter are inextricably interlinked. For discussion of the scientific study of consciousness, as well as related philosophy. I think our our bods are just built built to be conduits. Consciousness requires a brain but the brain can be artificial. And even if the consciousness does rely on a brain for awareness, and other things, does that automatically mean it will die when the brain dies? No. Cite. Life might as well be a movie. Most recent answer. This does not automatically include the practice of awareness or practice of being conscious. 100% of all demonstrated Consciousness that we know of in the universe, has all originated from a material brain of some sort. There's very little proof that consciousness is rooted in the brain. it is not a tangible thing, and the only reason you think it exists is because you exist. No brains, no colour. The body exists within the field of consciousness. . I believe the conciseness is not stored in the brain, but is received by it. If you would apply the same line of reasoning, a rock would not exist outside the consciousness of something. I don’t need proof leprechauns aren’t real to deduce that it’s so unlikely from the absence of evidence as to be pointless to think about. So, no, I didn’t miss the point at all. Alternatively, we propose that consciousness may not originate in the brain, although some aspects of human perception of consciousness may be dependent on the brain. Perhaps what you have in mind is that people say that we cannot explain how consciousness is entailed by the relevant physical states. No brain = no consciousness. My personal view is that we don't have any reasonable explanation of consciousness yet, but I see a material approach as offering the most productive path forward at this point in time. Same thing as for god, which is relevant because the two are faith without evidence. This would explain how these people suddenly gain clarity. That stuff is all a part of the brain, and like I said, I believe the consciousness, and mind/body are separate, but connected. Although for sure, all evidence points to that, and it definitely seems the most logical conclusion, the problem is that we’re limited to our own senses, and what we can see, observe and record, which is not necessarily the entire picture. "There is no empirically established explanatory framework for understanding how consciousness can exist independently and outside of the brain. In other words, the “mind” is a field that exists around the brain; it picks up information from outside the brain and communicates it to the brain in an extremely fast process. " Consciousness is emergent. Consciousness is your subjective experience. You can get a ‘dead’ brain and stimulate 'random' electrical activity — this is not necessarily conscious. Your claim, that consciousness exists after the brain dies, is the extraordinary one. The consciousness did not deteriorate at all. Further, most examples of 'out of body' experiences that scientists care to study are found to be consistent with natural, known phenomena bound to the mechanics of the brain. That needs to be structure by something to provide thinking. In this case, what they mean is, in the first place, that no one has furnished an explanation of this kind -- at least none But I watched a Ted talk dennett gave about consciousness being an illusion, and yet all of his examples were how our brain can get fooled by illusions in the contents of consciousness, which seemed not to be hitting at the issue of consciousness itself being an illusion, so I hope his book is clearer about this than the talk was. My toe tissues are not conscious. Sep 6, 2022 · Neuroscience today says consciousness is generated by and localized in the brain because it emerges from brain activity. In the case of the color red, it is the phenomenon of a brain interpreting the wavelength that a particular photon has. They are an interpretation of a brain of a certain type of light with a certain energy, that's it. I have seen some people suggest that consciousness could exist outside of the brain and that sparked my curiosity. The brain creating consciousness "seems" to be the most "practical" value until one realizes that for the brain to create consciousness (if one also believes consciousness ceases to exist at death), the brain must magically create it ex nihilo, that is, by causing something that does not exist to inexplicably come into existence. Anesthesia, blunt force trauma studies, recreational drug use, simple neuroscience, the list goes on. The something is the brain. It isn't tied to a single part of the brain, it emerges from the functions of the brain as a whole. Consciousness has to be pulled From the world because that is the world And when we die the energy energy phase is right back in to the pool all as it has a million other times. Members Online In the same vein, all of the energies and biophysical phenomena that the brain experiences as consciousness do indeed exist independently and outside of the brain (e. This is of course a possible theory that can be proposed as an alternative to the conventional narrative. What science says is NOT "there is no consciousness after a brain dies" but that there is no evidence of consciousness after its brain dies. Olga Danylenko Hi u/FlakyJackfruit9892, . Consciousness is an emergent phenomenon of a complex, large group of interconnected, interacting neurons. Apr 2, 2024 · If it's true that one can be conscious of life outside the body while in a coma with no brain function, then it leaves the question of where our consciousness is located unresolved. Long story short, there is no evidence whatsoever which suggests consciousness can exist outside the brain; in fact it goes against most of what we know in neuroscience. unless Posted by u/numberonepaofag - No votes and 210 comments I think you’re wrong to say it’s indisputable that consciousness is created in the brain. The burden of proof is on you. , in a coma) but still are “conscious” because they still have subjective experiences. Lol, there weren't too many choices when I first chose the tag, so I picked one that was closest. This new machine has many advantages: It is immune to decay, and perhaps it will allow you to live forever. Sure, the brain processes information, but it does so in a completely different t manner than a computer does, so referring to things like the brain's hardware, software, and OS is just incorrect at all but the most trivial of levels. , physics, chemistry, and The other option is that consciousness exists in another "dimension" which our brains tap into. We have no indication that consciousness exists outside the brain. Everything points to consciousness being a byproduct of our brains. Electrical activity in the brain is not In fact, Fenwick believes that consciousness actually exists independently and outside of the brain as an inherent property of the universe itself like dark matter and dark energy or gravity. ” Which is why the comparisons to light/eyes and sound/ears is terrible. ” Consciousness is the presence of subjective experience. It's also a question of the nature of time, and Einstein himself said the passage of time is an illusion, which means that the "past" is alive. We noticed you are a pretty new Reddit account, so we just wanted to let you know to check out the subreddit rules here and maybe have a read through our Frequently Asked Questions - they make for fascinating reading! It implies that consciousness is a purely-physical phenomenon, and therefore it should, theoretically, be possible (though not necessarily practical) to simulate it. it cannot be observed from the outside, so if they copied your brain, atom for atom, and you died and your clone replaced you, it would make no difference whatsoever. ” We must define brain. Consciousness does not exist “out there. But does this mean the cosmos has a consciousness of its own? Yes it’s created by YOUR brain (mind actually). My best guess is that consciousness is due to some fascinating feature of the brain. Everything you experience is a result of physical processes in the brain, but these experiences have no effect on physical processes. Neither are my hair follicles. , physics, chemistry, and The soul/consciousness is not in the body. It's produced by the brain, but it's not dependent on it to exist. I know my body exists as a physical experience in my consciousness/mind, but the hypothesis that it also exists as a material Body external of consciousness mind is superfluous and efficient. Consciousness is the subjective experience of the most abstract components of human homeostasis, those behaviors which exist not on the level of directly responding to the change in the environment, but rather changes within the response mechanism itself to adapt to potential future circumstances. There may be other theories. A thinking agent does not actually "think". It's just that hard of a problem Explore the debate on whether consciousness can exist outside the brain, as discussed by experts in neuroscience. If a conscious brain would freeze in the sense of every atom suddenly coming to a complete standstill in relation to every other atom in the brain, and then after some time unfreeze the brain would not be able to tell that it would have been in a frozen state from internal information. Outside of our brain colors would be more similar to blades of grass: all the same "thing," but all different lengths. Aug 11, 2022 · Consciousness can not simply be reduced to neural activity alone, researchers say. Even without eyes, we can measure light. If those blades of grass were light waves, we would see each individual blade of grass as a different "hue," with shorter blades being closer to red, medium being closer to green, and longer ones being closer to violet. To claim that consciousness doesn't require a brain, you must first demonstrate that consciousness can or does exist without a materialistic "brain". My answer to your question is no because if we make a sufficiently complex sensory network for an AI, I believe the AI could be conscious but then that would simply be a brain. So either it does originate in the brain in ways science has not confirmed just yet, or everything is just an illusion. Dec 19, 2018 · It then “transmits wave information into the brain tissue, that … is instrumental in high-speed conscious and subconscious information processing,” Dirk wrote. Jun 3, 2021 · Our recent paper argues that consciousness involves no separate independent psychological process distinct from the brain itself, just as there’s no additional function to digestion that In the same vein, all of the energies and biophysical phenomena that the brain experiences as consciousness do indeed exist independently and outside of the brain (e. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. But what is the point in being strapped into a machine when you can't change anything. Members Online Nov 1, 2019 · We know that consciousness exists not through experiments but through our immediate awareness of our feelings and experiences. But the wondrous experience of consciousness itself seems to require a brain to give rise to it and a brain-based mind to perceive it. The brain produces consciousness but consciousness, whatever that is, exists in some alternate Jun 25, 2024 · Research has found the universe is remarkably similar in structure to the human brain. Obviously there is no consensus on how consciousness works, but I’ll answer this based on what most people seem to agree upon. Reddit. In philosophy, “conscious” is not usually equated with “alert. The study of the brain is therefore entwined with the study of Dec 7, 2021 · I can replace your brain with a machine that is its equal in every way, so that from the outside, nobody could tell the difference. " "By altering the delicate electrochemical balance within the neural circuitry inside your head, the basic ground state of what it is to “be” is — temporarily — abolished" But while theoretical physicists can happily propose ideas such as the predictions of string theory—from ten (or more) dimensions of space to the vast landscape of possible universes—and still have their work get a fair hearing, it is considered a risk to one’s reputation to suggest that consciousness might exist outside the brain. Brain is physical aspect of mind on the 3D plane. So no. Consciousness is an emergent property of a sufficiently complex sensory network. e consciousness is simply the ability to monitor your own thoughts and judgements. Where exactly is memory stored "outside of the brain"? Or does it extend beyond the brain? The question of how consciousness and matter interrelate has been characterised by the philosopher David Chalmers as the ‘hard problem. Single cells do not have consciousness. Even without ears, we can measure sound. You could probably argue that consciousness emerges from the brain/body interface as Oct 18, 2023 · A recent experiment suggests the brain is not too warm or wet for consciousness to exist as a quantum wave that connects with the rest of the universe. Is there anything 'real' about color besides our perception of it, do the colors exist outside our perception in any way? Colours do not exist in any way outside of perception, except for the equivalence wavelength/colour. According to one theory that I've heard, the brain is just a receiver of consciousness and when the brain dies consciousness still exists, just like when smart phone breaks, the internet still exist. However it then requires some elaboration. Sep 7, 2022 · What is consciousness? The term “consciousness” means different things to different audiences. We also suggest that awareness also extends beyond the brain. It doesn't matter if the brain creates consciousness; it matters how that consciousness interacts with the world. From a lay perspective, the fact of consciousness (here meaning awareness) is so self-evident that the only question that may arise is why anyone would consider consciousness to be mysterious in the first place, akin to asking a fish, “What is water?” One thing that is worth considering is the epihenomenal theory of consciousness, which essentially states that the consciousness is a biproduct that arises out of the workings of the brain, but does not influence it. No, people who say this assume consciousness is something immaterial which I have to "prove" is caused by the brain and so they think me defining it as what the brain does is "presupposing my own conclusion. The brain has been deteriorating for years, how does it come back. Jun 26, 2019 · In the same vein, all of the energies and biophysical phenomena that the brain experiences as consciousness do indeed exist independently and outside of the brain (e. Then there is the hybrid option. If consciousness does not reside in the brain or body, "where" is it? I think Sam takes the reasonable position that consciousness is almost certainly affiliated with the brain due to the plethora of neurocorrelates that can be measured objectively and linked to subjective experiences, however he wouldn't rule out the possibility that consciousness does not originate in the brain. No scientist knows why or how consciousness exists. Consciousness is something like a self-experienced indivisible substance that has no physical source or a cause, and it is the very being/existing. Brad Jesness Raw consciousness exists outside the brain. No, consciousness isn’t just electrical activity in the brain. But if our brain is kind of a computer made with neurons, synapses, and other things, why does something as immaterial as consciousness can exist? Why should we think consciouness is immaterial? Anyway consciouness lets you do lots of things, like flexible control, distance future planning and that sort of stuff They claim laughable things like I'm "presupposing my own conclusion" by defining consciousness as what the brain does. I'm an engineer/mathematician by trade and have what I consider a justified belief that materialism has provided What I wonder, is, how does this happen. Only you can experience your emotions. Hence, in Fenwick’s view, the brain does not create or produce consciousness; rather, it filters it. The total absence of evidence that it does is enough to prove the affirmative. The internet doesn't disappear just because a smart phone breaks. Jun 26, 2019 · In fact, Fenwick believes that consciousness actually exists independently and outside of the brain as an inherent property of the universe itself like dark matter and dark energy or Jan 14, 2020 · In our standard view of things, consciousness exists only in the brains of highly evolved organisms, and hence it exists only in a tiny part of the universe and only in very recent history. In fact, Fenwick believes that consciousness actually exists independently and outside of the brain as an inherent property of the universe itself like dark matter and dark energy or gravity. g. Consciousness is not outside nor inside of the brain. There are certainly examples of people who are “unconscious” in the medical sense of not being alert (e. , physics, chemistry, and quantum events). Thus for anyone looking at another person's brain, there are two versions of that brain, the consciousness-composed object called a "brain" that is basically just a creation of the brain of the person is looking at another person's "brain", and the other person's brain that is not a creation of the brain of the person looking at that brain, i. Consciousness does not exist without or outside of a brain. oiuexcpmwkhikimqhhxtmepjksxhfifikdvaqepkikfcebnou
