Minthara and halsin in party. She will not talk to me, though.
Minthara and halsin in party The Halsin vs. Time to reload :'( Reply reply Tierce • Get Minthara first, then go get Halsin for Ragzlin. Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • Juxix Kill all goblin leaders (knock out Minthara) and then speak to Halsin, there will be a Cutscene, he will thank you for killing all goblin leaders, then go to moonrise tower and Minthara will be there. I AM SO EXCITED. I ♥♥♥♥ you not. Gather your party and venture forth! Obviously, Minthara doesn't know that Halsin exists at all and I couldn't talk to her about it. A shame she is locked behind the path of mass slaughter of NPCs with multiple 3 Act storylines, including the breaking of certain companion storylines. Do you need to sleep with Minthara at the Goblin party to romance her? No. Be warned that Minthara can be buggy no matter what, especially if you recruit her through the non-normal method (knocking her out vs siding with her against the Grove). But I heard Minthara is pretty barebones. Gather your party and venture forth! There was a (non cheating) method to get Halsin and Minthara to join your camp, that was removed from the game in patch 1. Reply reply chaosmosis • • i know you can get Minthara and recruit Halsin by freeing him and not particpating in the raid on the grove, but my understanding is that this leads to the tieflings dying on the road. Reply reply Balthierlives Minthara being negative approval with you isn't because of sharing a camp with Halsin (they don't acknowledge each other's existence at all), it happened to me because I teleported back to Act 1 without her in my party (and therefore without triggering her "I will stay and plot Ketheric's demise" line) Minthara & Halsin Act 2 - Spoilers I just need to share this somewhere because I legitimately wasn't sure I would ever get to see Minthara. She doesn't have anything to say about Halsin. Honor mode and the wounded mind flayer. Halsin joins the player's party: Depending on the choices you make, Halsin may eventually join the player's party and become a valuable ally. He was excited and told me to await him that night. Then Minthara bugged out and I had to kill her and resurrect her, then everything was fine. (OC) 2. Gather your party and venture forth! Best. There's no companions preventing you to recruit another. anyone know why ? also, I have become the Slayer. jackclsf • I accidentally have Minthara in my party with Karlach still in my party. 6 - Save halflings, save zevlor and finish the act. Enter camp to go get Minthara in my party, end up surprised as heck to find Halsin next to her. Doing my second playthrough now (half-orc Cleric/Paladin of Selune romancing Shadowheart) and thought it would be fun to try recruiting Minthara. i read somewhere that larian did not intend for players to have both minthara and halsin, didnt know this and i randomly received backpacks and at the time didnt question it (idk why man) and im now realising it was halsin's then minthara's No, knocking Minthara out is considered killing her too. Minthara permanently leaves the party. After her disappearance, Halsin's tent will be restored and Halsin will walk back to his original position. Gale will too if his opnion is low and you fail his checks. Decisions, Decisions. Hoping this fix means we can keep both Halsin and Minthara. Finish all your business in Act 1. Worth wandering around your camp to see if you can find him hanging out on the ground somewhere 😸 III is based on a modified version of the Dungeons & Dragons 5th edition (D&D 5e) tabletop RPG ruleset. But, once again, I am unable to converse with her or remove her from my party after the initial convo at camp. In act 2, I freed Minthara and helped Halsin remove the curse. Make sure your script extender is updated and properly installed. At least for me, it's always been that way, so it seems Halsin: "I'm leaving" ;) I'm not a Halsin fan. More importantly, buy anything of Dammon. Walnut stampede! Super_Yamcha 11 months ago #10. Here, I killed Gut and knocked Minthara out. I can think of little else. At least she didn't for me. The only real switch is Karlach and Minthara, but I intend to keep that slot for a melee focused character to balance my Tav and Gale as spellcasters. And, Minthara will be able to be saved, will be conversational, and will be fully interactable as a normal companion. I think she's the Anti-Halsin, so maybe they're programmed similarly. (I’m at the outdoors campsite) THEN I FIND THIS MAN WHITTLING AWAY UP THE STAIRS OF THE Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • Crimson_Halation (I only spared Minthara) And I didn't rescue Halsin until I had Minthara. And there you have it! Besides the tiefling slaughter, everything else I played as a "good" playthrough without issue! I won't be finishing this playthrough, but I'm glad I did it for any of y'all that wanted these two together (and from the look of it, Halsin is Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • Far-Inspection-9990 Minthara + Halsin NOTE: I'd killed Gut, freed Halsin and told him to wait in the Worg pens. Knocked her out at the Goblin Camp (I handled her second and immediately went to Dror who I attacked while he was talking to the dead mindflayer and received the necessary Quest completions) Gather your party and venture forth! So in a pre-Patch 5/unmodded playthrough, you could simultaneously romance either Astarion or Shadowheart alongside Halsin or Minthara (whichever you recruited). Minthara and Halsin General Questions - [SPOILERS] Is it possible to have both Halsin and Minthara accompany you by just knocking Minthara out rather than killing her? Or does the game still count this as a death like some other interactions? I want to have Minthara for this playthrough but I don't want the Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • TheMinor-69er. Now I'm wondering if she's gone for good, or there's a place where I can pick her back up in Act 2? Can I get Halsin back? After killing the goblin camp and having the tiefling party you need to go back to minthara and have her attack the druids. Reply reply I personally got Halsin recruited to my party (so did his portal request), and added him to my party. And yes, Halsin and Minthara sharing tent does things to my shipper brain. upvotes Halsin is currently in my camp chilling. Met Halsin in the Alpha, so I somewhat know what he's like. Reply reply PancakeXCandy • The only way to get rid of a companion is to kill them or force them to leave. Minthara even has dialogue for curing the shadow curse, so that's good. Financial_Log_8543 • Halsin will kill you, whll and karlach are going to leave and gale is the only person that I need to convince to not leave at all. I wonder if there are any mods out there that let us get both Halsin and Minthara as full companions without resorting to buggy practices that involves me speed running past the grove? I know its possible, but due to Minthara clearly being unable to talk after saving her from Moonrise I get bugged hard. . Too bad you can't get Minthara, Minratha, AND Karlach in the same party though. Also if you skip the Grove vs Goblin and go straight to act 2 and save minthara (if you don't want to get your hands dirty while also want to get minthara) Halsin will be found dead in the worg pen. Oh no, in all of Act 2, they are happily bunking together. Top. Reply reply LloydSatan Minthara seems way more interesting and complex than Halsin, who has the personality of a sack filled with leaves and twigs. Even if you ignore the Grove conflict, Halsin won’t join your party afaik. The Grove will be decimated (along with the shopkeeper), Halsin will be unavailable and the Shadow Curse After obtaining Minthara, decline to put her in the active party as many of the cultists will now have a grudge against the Drow Paladin. Minsc: Boo! Ugh, doing my first tactician playthrough and really need that cave bear for Ragzlin lol. People said there would be confrontation. ADMIN MOD Recruiting Minthara and Halsin . - Leave via the Mountain Pass *without* completing the goblin raid. The party can fight Minthara as part of the quest After agreeing to seize the grove with Minthara, the party must talk to Halsin and immediately travel to the Emerald Grove. This unexpected turn led to some unexpected outcomes, sparking laughter and confusion among players. Well beside Halsin/Minthara that are mutually exclusive, unless you find a very twisted and not intended way. She’s a deadly Paladin that wields two blades at once and serves the Cult of the Absolute. Do not make the Goblins hostile. If you do this, free Halsin and kill both of the other Goblin leaders, you will have saved the Grove. Two companions in Baldur’s Gate 3 were impossible to recruit together due to their beliefs and their parts in the story. Minthara was in the cutscene with Ketheric. Now it's possible to get both Halsin and Minthara in same party in Act 2 but leaks abd dataminer have allegedly found strings of code for camp dialogue scene that will forces you to choose between Halsin and Minthara in Gather your party and venture forth! Way to recruit Halsin and Minthara, and save Sazza? comments. Now i am in the mission to kill the goblin leaders. She’d be more tied to the MSQ, so I might be willing to let Halsin stay with the Druids even. On the fifth dialogue with him, there should be two options, if there's a third that says "The druids are already dead, by my hand" this won't work. But now that you can have both Halsin and Minthara, I had the thought: can you romance Astarion/Shadowheart and Halsin and Minthara? Share Add a Comment. Baldur's Gate III is based on a modified version of the If I remove someone from my party prior to talking to Minthara, she will join and I can level her up and change her inventory. Baldur's Gate III is based on a modified version of the Dungeons & Dragons 5th edition (D&D To be fair, Halsin wasn't even going to be a companion so the fact that he even has a romance is already pretty good. I read that in the latest patch you can do this if you knock out Minthara and rescue her in moonrise towers in act 2. Halsin and Minthara are two opposing companions in Baldur’s Gate 3. Talk to Halsin, exhaust dialogue options with random talking. Old. Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • Achaion34. Wyll, Karlach, and Halsin leave your party permanently if you side with the goblins against the druids/tieflings, which is required to recruit Minthara. this is similar to Baldurs Gate 2 Slayer. Do not talk to Minthara. All BG3 Items There was code for having Minthara available to join your party, because you could choose to side with her over the Grove. Some have even reported her not showing up at Moonrise even if Gather your party and venture forth! Can you go back and ask Halsin to join you? If you're in Minthara's room there's a ladder that lets you go to the prison without walking past Gut's area. Yes, you can recruit both Minthara and Halsin. So I did got both Minthara & Halsin recruited through a seemly normal process rather using the bugged approach (no need to leave Halsin in the goblin camp). If you want to get Mintara and Halsin at the same time, you will need to "free" Halsin and tell him to "stay". Those two are Minthara and Halsin, both on opposite sides of the conflict in Act 1 of the game. (Same for Karlach and Wyll, both will leave the party if you try to raid the grove with them) To get them both you have to side with the grove and kill the goblin leaders, but use non-lethal attacks to knock out minthara rather than killing her. The sequence is you first speak with the girl right next to the man sleeping, then speak with halsin in your camp, then speak with halsin in Las Light Inn, then go to the house of healing and kill the boss to get a lute, comeback to speak with halsin, do the portal encounter, then go to the house with flowers meet Oliver, then speak about it Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • ma_dude28 In the one playthrough I recruited Minthara I let Halsin die in the Shadowfell portal. We would be praised as heroes. Don't think any of this is considered a spoiler but I put the tag on anyways. They occupy the same tent in camp though (maybe because they were intended to be mutually exclusive, idk). - Recruit Minthara in Act 2 as usual - she will be in the tower. Halsin did not comment on Minthara at all, and Minthara had very little to say about Halsin. Passing this persuasion check will A collection of Minthara's remarks and overhead conversations with other characters. He never came 🥲 My DUrge can't get any spicy action in this Siding with Minthara. From the gameplay point, Paladin wouldn’t go amiss in the party. A waste of my talents. So lets say I failed Halsin's mission and he died in the process, can I hire Minthara Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • LukeDies Quest Help I killed Priestess Gut but I couldn't figure out how to isolate and kill the Bugbear and Drow leaders for Halsin's quest. That Minthara’s dialogue you can ask her about all companions and there is no option for Halsin. Stop squirming. And after having a long rest Halsin Halsin vs Minthara . Zelvor will offer you the Crown (among other goodies) for your efforts. Knocking her out instead of killing her, granting mercy if you lower her life to certain point (like with the hag), or even by dialogue. The tieflings will be stuck in the camp, but protected thanks to Kagha stopping the ritual. All was fine they both showed up at the epilogue party! Reply reply more reply More replies More replies More replies More replies More replies. If you rescue Halsin, he will force you to wipe out the goblin (that includes minthara, even though you already recruited her). Just hanging around the main hall. Reply reply JustifytheMean • The Druids as I found out in numerous conversations are a bunch of religious nuts According to a reddit post from yesterday, in order to have Karlach and Wyll in the same party as Minthara is you have to completely ignore the attack the grove quest. I am over 70hrs into the game and I find this out. I did this and it worked for me. BUGS I started a good Durge playthrough just a few days ago. You save Minthara and she joins your party. But she wants this power for Make her temp hostile, go to goblin camp, run straight for minthara, make temp hostile, use non lethal attks to knock her out, then kill the rest of the leaders, get halsin and leave. Reply reply Magewhisper • 7. (D&D 5e) tabletop RPG ruleset. Controversial. The other companions have acknowledged Minthara, but Halsins just keeps talking about the shadow curse. If you choose this way, you can capture Minthara and the absolutist attack on the tieflings makes more sense than just attacking travellers. I did so and now I'm in act 2 at moonrise, but I like her character and I like adding her skill set to the party. From bg3. Im just curious if people think Larian will I remember seeing a post saying in a new patch you can recruit both by knocking out minthara in act 1. these ranged from being able to use sponges to clean your party to spider-meat being poisonous if you lick it. If goblins were orcs, or someone smarter but still What I remember doing was: Rescued Halsin from his cell and talked to him, went into act 2 without triggering the raid, rescued Minthara and added her to my party without long resting, traveled back to act 1, long rested, and Halsin showed up in camp. Halsin: I make no apologies for knowing what is important to me. But yeah Halsin and Minthara could certainly use some more romance scenes,specially in Act 2 since it plays an important part on both of their characters. Reply reply More replies More replies No, in the current state of the game, recruiting Halsin requires you to kill the three leaders of goblin camp, Minthara included. Even after rejecting Absolute Minthara is still power hungry. Open comment After she escapes, Minthara will join your party as a permanent party member. Thus you get Halsin in act 1 (sort of. ADMIN MOD Knocked out Minthara but Halsin still won't leave? (Act 1) BUGS You've knocked out Minthara and completed the main storyline bosses of act 1 and you're ready to go back to the Grove and tell everyone the good news. Minthara was looking to destroy the grove - Halsin's grove - and Halsin was a prisoner there trying to protect his people. And Minthara will struggle to move through the environment in your party. Kept Halsin in my party, kicked another person out when we got to camp after rescuing her. Halsin: Back to the dirt, druid. To get her to join, you must help Is it possible to get both as party members if I incapacitate Minthra when she attacks the Grove rather than killing her? Don't know if it matters but after she left to attack the So I knocked Minthara out in Act 1 and rescued her at Moonrise. Technically, the only change made with Patch #5 in this matter is that Halsin will not automatically die if Minthara is alive at the very first instant the player party sets foot beyond the boundaries of Act 1. I just found out that you can have both Minthara and Halsin in your party. He is being a hypocrite making exceptions for a Vampire Spawn, a Sharran, a warlock, and a mage with an explosive in his chest. Can I use the other mod WITH this mod You can have both Minthara and Halsin in your party. Minthara never bugged out on me either like some ppl Baldur’s Gate 3 may finally let you recruit both Halsin and Minthara. Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • Terraban. Was told I could sheep her and carry her to Moonrise. A community all about Gather your party and venture forth! DrMatis. Reply reply Fuzzy_Difficulty_668 • I know I can't have both on my team. Help him, and kill all of the goblins in the room. ADMIN MOD Halsin and Minthara at camp? Act 2 - Spoilers I just got Minthara to join after infiltrating Moonrise (I saved the grove) and I got SO confused when I saw Minthara where Halsin usually is. Best. Idk if I should or just continue and make a new play later. Bad news is I haven't gotten any ultimatium. I did have some mods but I'm 99. I have both of them on my current playthrough. Ad placeholder. BG3 is the third main game in the Baldur's Gate series. Into act 2, I entered the main door of moonrise towers, Minthara went downstairs to prison. You will need to venture northward, back into the Shadow-Curse, and towards the Normally, to recruit Minthara, players need to infiltrate the Cult of the Absolute and then reveal the location of the Emerald Grove — then plot to attack. With patch #5, as long as Minthara has been knocked out once, the script that is meant to auto-kill Halsin will not run. Archived post. General Questions - [SPOILERS] I just plain and simple don't like druids. After going around finishing Waukeens Rest and Auntie Ethel, I went back to kill Dror Ragzin and save Halsin. I feel like he would at least tolerate her until then but not be particularly happy about it. Okay, just the one “Grace is bestowed by nature, not me. ADMIN MOD Minthara and Halsin sharing a tent Act 3 - Spoilers Has lead to some awkward moments 😅 Minthara was sitting right there last night when Halsin propositioned my Tav, and presumably noticed when he snuck off later that night Fast-forward to this morning when she asks to read Tav’s thoughts, and I Remember, Halsin is in to threesomes and foursomes. I recruited her after freeing her from prison. Reply reply Top 1% Rank by size . Lost halsin and minthara the same day on honor Mode lol Reunited Thaniel and Oliver without Halsin in party comments. The only odd thing was Minthara and Halsin sharing the same tent/bed (depending on the camp) but tbh that was more funny than anything else. ) Then in act 2 you can save/recruit Minthara. Because this will remove Halsin from the campaign, it will be better to check the state of the Halsin's quests in ACT 2 before you play this cutscene. After If I'm understanding correctly, you can have Minthara AND Halsin in the same party? If so, can you have sexy time with Minthara, Halsin, and Astarion all at the same time? I need to know, Minthara can be saved and recruited to the party. Patch 5 added a whole load of content on its own. However someone told me in a FB group they were able to recruit both Minthara and Halsin through their play through by following certain tasks. I'm sure developing some ultimatum, or perhaps a more coherent way for both to join the party, is entirely probable. I assume this is a bug and not meant to be possible? I've read that there is a supposed choice between them that Halsin is meant to give you, but it's not implemented. 3. In Act II they share a tent because they’re not intended to both be there, but it’s possible. So I reloaded my save and convinced Halsin that I'm only interested in him and my other relationship is over, no need to talk to anyone. When in Act 2 area I found my way to Moonrise with the Drider by convincing him to take Shadowheart and Astarion are the only polyamorous companions in the game and only with Halsin. Their intended quest lines involve thwarting the other. Minthara and Halsin bug BUGS while trying to rescue halsin or minthara they keep trapping me in endless dialogue. Everyone else is recruitable and able to be partied with each other, even if you take an evil route and destroy the Grove. New. There are other repercussions for getting the two faction Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • YoungSanchez. its just a guess. Clickbait title out of the way! Since everybody's talking about Minthara's recruitment again, I think it's worthwhile to bring up a really helpful guide by u/IjustHaveAsprite who posted a guide a couple of weeks ago on how to recruit Minthara the "good" way without ignoring the Grove/Goblin situation. Gather your party and When Minthara joined the party, Halsin gained inspiration. But this should only be possible if you knocked her unconscious at the goblin camp. Just don't like em. If this was doable before, it is not now, as that is not a choice upon right- clicking. Recruited Minthara in prison, escaped via back-side of tower. Went to Moonrise towers. Halsin and Minthara will likewise Here are a few things that can forever lock Halsin out from the list of potential companions in a run. Then you return for Halsin and tell him about the sleeping guy. Additionally, Wyll will not tolerate this choice and will actually turn against your party if you side with the Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • Ekkkkkkkkkkko . Went to towers. I plan to knock out minthara while kill all the goblins so she will be at the moonrise for be recruit. I like that she is all for getting all the power she can in Act 3 so she'll happily do things the other companions don't want to. I avoided going down Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • Popular-Art-2099 . I've cleared enough content to head to The Shadow-cursed lands. Act 2 - Spoilers So, I'm curious as to what will happen if Halsin died during the portal quest. No spoilers please, but try to recruit Minthara into the party again at the end of Act 2, dismiss someone in your party if need be. But Halsin keeps telling you you have to stay and help him kill the goblin camp Minthara's sister Minratha and Karlach go together like peanut butter and jelly. upvotes Just don't resolve Halsin/Grove/Raid, and Minthara will show up in Act 2 for you to recruit. Zevlor also sells some nice gloves for a healer. Share Sort by: Best. In brief: yes, you can side with the goblins, have a fun night with Minthara, dodge Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • I agree, because at least before minthara and halsin had separate camp spots in the Lower City campsite, but for me post patch Halsin has no tent anywhere and just awkwardly stands around other peoples tents Reply reply More replies. Baldur's Gate III is based on a modified version of the Dungeons & Dragons 5th edition (D&D 5e) tabletop RPG ruleset. Thanks to Reddit user u/DJay_lost for sharing this method. SPOILER. It I just defeated Ketheric in the Mindflayer colony. The urge to just start all over to have every companion in my playthrough is driving me mad. Just started my second playthrough and Minthara was my favorite companion on the first one, is there anyway you can save Minthara and rescue Halsin? Archived post. Minthara is currently at the Goblin Camp chilling. Sometimes she will stop entirely, and I must take control of her instead of my character to get the group to It's impossible to recruit halsin if you raid the grove. Is there a way to recruit minthara and save the rifling’s? comments. But at act 2 when you recruit Minthara, Halsin Halsin does not want to take that chance with Minthara, but can be a total hypocrite taking chances with the existing party. Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • Also, it's coded into the game to be able to have both halsin and minthara because she has custom dialog when you ask what she thinks of halsin. But by keeping both stories unresolved, it becomes possible to recruit the pair together. This isn't a mod issue. Having both Halsin and Minthara share the same tent in camp looks quite wrong, both in terms of narrative and gameplay. I thought Halsin would give me an ultimatum, so I did Nathanial's whole thing before going to Moonrise the first time to save Minthara and the other prisoners. Gather your party and venture forth! About Halsin and Minthara. Minthara left party, can I get her back? Companions I recruited Minthara shortly after starting Act 2, then I decided to go back to Act 1 to finish up some other quests I accidentally skipped and she refused to follow me there. Wiping out the Grove doesn't seem to make her mad at you, at least for me. Halsin then joined my party. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Act 2 - Spoilers So I want to recruit Minthara but I don’t want to kill a bunch of refugees. I dismissed Halsin from my party but that didn't work, she still aggros. wiki < Minthara. Then kill Dror/the rest of the camp. Immediately beeline to Last Light. ”" Minthara: "Just give the word and I will kill the clown. Granted, it does take a little bit of a scummy method to achieve that (basically, you have to recruit Wyll and Karlach, kill them, then store their bodies Halsin is with you in camp, and recruitable in Act 2. But when talking to Halsin afterwards, he says we still need to take out the leaders. As of Full Release Patch 1, it's impossible to recruit Minthara and Halsin. 9999% sure they don't change the story at all She has a storyline but it’s narrowed in comparison with other companions (except Halsin). At the Emerald Grove, the party must side with the tieflings. If you want to recruit her, you have to go to her before him, make her Temporarily Hostile towards you, and knock her out. Then attempt to stealth kill the Leaders except Mintara, avoid battle with Mintara at So since we can get Minthara without killing the grove, I'm doing that. comments. Minthara/Banter. Gather your party and venture forth! I succeeded, there were some weird interactions like both Minthara and Halsin standing next to Thaniel like a small family (it was more concerning than wholesome) and the first time I talked to Minthara in camp she just straight up spoiled the entire plot of act 3 (lucky me I already finished the game once). A Comic Where Tav Settles a Debate About Mind Flayers. Levelled her up, and good to go. Minthara is an optional (and evil) party member in Baldur’s Gate 3. Also, BTW, although it came as a surprise to me - people were expecting a confrontation - nah, Halsin gained inspiration when Minthara joined the party. Gather your party and venture forth! Honestly I don't care about Halsin, if the choice was to kill Minthara or Halsin I would keep Minthara gamewise (to have all different classes, except monk, since I am sorc), but slaughtering the whole grove with tieflings and druids in it are not that appealing as slaughtering stupid goblins. So I tell her where the camp is and speak to Holsin, who says he'll join me in the fight. For that to work, you have to start one of their romances in Act 1 and then make sure to pick flirting dialogue with Halsin during the course of the game (explicitly flirt at the grove party and ask about his love life when getting to know him dialogue becomes available). Minthara Debate. Went to prison, rescued Minthara. 5 - Go to camp and you'll see minthara and halsin, now you can recruit halsin to the team. So that's nice. She will not talk to me, though. Healing a party member Relationship Out of combat Sneaking In combat Negative I will never let you fall. The kicker being Halsin would refuse to join a party with her, so it’s mutually exclusive, but not “has to be killed”. Saving Halsin & Minthara Origin Characters I have free sazza the goblin and halsin from the cage. I knocked her out at the Goblin Camp and proceeded through Acts 1 and 2 as usual- saved the Grove and the Tieflings, helped Halsin find Thaniel, and recruited him to my party. People found an exploit that allowed them to access that code even while still siding with the You can 100% get Both Minthara and Halsin in your party without issue. I knocked Minthara out in Act 1 and in Act 2 she's in moonrise facing trial. I feel like the option of recruiting Minthara at Moonrise should come at the cost of losing Halsin post shadow curse plot. He will travel to the inn. ADMIN MOD Halsin and Minthara apaprently share a tent Origin Characters Share Sort by: Best. It didn't involve any glitches, although the method was kinda convoluted. This could be especially true if you choose to side with Minthara and help her achieve her goals. Resting after the fight likely woke her up, and she Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • baggedBoneParcel. BG3 is Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • jurrassicrabbit. I wanna do a alternate outcome where I save Halsin in his prison, don’t kill the leaders at the camp, snitch out the grove, but defend it at the last You won't be locking yourself out, can go back to Act 1 areas until pretty late yourself, it's just Minthara (and Halsin) who won't step a foot in Act 1 ever again. Not only does it cost the lives of all the inhabitants of the Grove, but it also costs Halsin, another potential companion. If you join her and wipe out the To add both of them to your party you have to save Halsin and make him wait for you in the prison, then recruit Minthara first and him later in Act 2. Reply reply Gather your party and venture forth! Technically speaking, Halsin/Minthara is the only choice you have to make. Open comment sort options. If you haven’t already realized, recruiting Minthara exacts a heavy price. i think its the dialogue of trying to leave the area or quest, mithara says 'what is it, whats wrong?' and it gives me the options of tell her to stay there or to leave the convo, but on either option Find Minthara, fail a couple checks, but she still gets taken to the prison. Sort by: A community all about Baldur's Gate III, the role-playing video game by Larian Studios. One of the articles said that this only works if you make her Minthara Baenre & Halsin; Jaheira & Minthara Baenre; Minthara Baenre & Lae'zel; Jaheira (Baldur's Gate) Lae'zel (Baldur's Gate) Minthara Baenre; Tav (Baldur's Gate) Halsin (Baldur's Gate) Dreams and Nightmares; Nightmares; Implied/Referenced Torture; When the party needs a break, Wyll suggests that they participate in a Waterdelvian midwinter festival of Then you can have a moment in act 2 when you can decide to have Halsin join the party, or to have Halsin stay behind and bring Kagha along on a sort of pilgrimage or learning tour. Ideally I'd like to make it so the teiflings don't die on the road, but I understand that might not be possible with Minthara since that probably requires killing Okay, so as I said I knocked out Minthara, got Halsin out of jail, and then went with him and killed Gut and the other dude. - Enter the Goblin Camp and free Halsin. As a good party I might try to fix her, and Halsin could be a huge help back at his Grove. It is possible, im in a run with both right now 1-dont trigger the "kill goblin leaders" mission, 2-knock down minthara and kill the other two leaders, 3-dont save Sazza the goblin, dont worry for not triggering the mission, you will save the tieflins and rescue Halsin just the same. Of course some specific story decisions might make them leave the party, but there's no decision in the game beside Halsin/Minthara that will result into making one leave or make leave another if not. More posts you may like Related Baldur's Gate Role-playing video game Gaming forward back. If you knock her out and kill the other 2 leaders, the grove is safe. Halsin permanently leaves the party. The quest markers are still on the map, pointing to Gut and other guy’s bodies. I looted the grove and went to the goblin party with her. To do so you must enable non-lethal attack and knock her out while doing the "kill the three leaders" quest for Zevlor/Halsin. is it possible that if I transform into Slayer too many times, people will start leaving the party. Gather your party and venture forth! Easily done: go to goblin camp, slaughter everyone BUT when you fight Minthara make sure to toggle non lethal damage on JUST FOR HER, once she's knocked out, slaughter the rest of the goblins; now go to the prison and save Halsin, quest will progress normally, now when you get to the shadowcursed lands you can do whatevs, just make absolutely sure to go to Moonrise Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • laezel, gale, and Astarion are by withers each with a bed, and shart, Minsc, Wyll, jaheira, and minthara/halsin are in the area off the side opposite the resting bed, and halsin takes the hallway floor if you have minthara on your team I believe Reply reply More replies More replies More replies. She can also be romanced. And Halsin's ultimatum is, likely, a whole cutscene that needs to be scripted, acted, animated and voiced. Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • BoboMan6699. She was the sole survivor of the camp in the end. All larian did is moved Minthara to moonrise, instead of having us do it through sheep method. That changes a lot of things. The "cheese" way to recruit Minthara - introduced by Larian in a patch because she was a popular companion who players wanted without having to raid the Grove - is to knock her unconscious while she's Temporarily Hostile so you can recruit in Act 2. Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • IllusivePuppy. There are datamined dialogues in recent patches implying that it would be possible to recruit Halsin without killing Minthara if Kagha completes the rite of thorns. I don't know, good luck! This leads to Wyll and Karlach leaving your party permanently and Halsin being unrecruitable. (If the shadowcurse has been lifted) Halsin: We have lifted the shadow curse, but a new challenge awaits us. I’m also trying to test out another theory whether I can Because Halsin is not a party member until you finish that quest. The next day, I found Minthara in Zevlor's cave. Note, there isn't enough beds for all the companions so halsin is left without a bed. 8. Be aware tho that if you manage to get Halsin and Minthara, the latter won't have a tent at camp as they both use the same spot. ADMIN MOD Minthara + Halsin how? General Questions - [SPOILERS] Could someone share how to keep both Minthara and Halsin, I heard its doable now. Q&A Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online. 6) You progress the quest from Halsin until he offers to become permanent Hi everyone So I hard that since patch 5 it was now possible to get Minthara without siding with the goblin, on my first save I managed to knock her out with non lethal dmg but when I went to camp her body actually disappeared and I had the first dream visitor sequence, when I came out of camp her body disappeared. Killed Malus Thorm, woke up sleeping guy, and helped Halsin get Thaniel. pretty sure he means how did you get all the companions without them randomly quitting the party? siding with minthara alone nromally makes will, karlach and halsin instantly abandon you. Halsin died in the manner, and all tieflings In Act 1 Halsin and Minthara were intended to be diametrically opposed, meaning they wanted opposite things, and siding with one would pit the other against you. That way you could rescue Halsin and still have her alive to show up--though probably furious with you for destroying her plans. Jaheira: Jaheira! Even legends can die. Just don’t bring Halsin when you’re trying to recruit her. Now that Minthara is en route, go to Halsin. Karlach: You can talk of little else too. ADMIN MOD Spoilers - Minthara and Halsin in the same playthrough . But I kinda don't want her in my camp taking over Halsin's tent. All this must be done without a long rest. Roah will be available to you later as a quest NPC/trader. Well i mean i had halsin and minthara both recuited camp before but halsin always dies in camp with her around Reply reply Upstairs-Search-1773 • • Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online. Go to Moonrise (after Last Light intro) and finish the recruitment quest for Minthara. Why remove this? Seems really counter to the rest of the game. She was very happy and thankful. When you kill Dror Ragzlin, the entire camp goes hostile, including Minthara. For Minthara you'd have to do the sheep glitch or if you're on pc, get the mod. What you're seeing is a result of the tents clipping on top of each other, but luckily Halsin and Minthara recognize collision and don't sit in each other's laps. ADMIN MOD Question regarding Halsin and Minthara . Taking Minthara hard locks you out of Halsin. Baldur's Gate III is based on a modified version of the Dungeons & Dragons 5th edition Allow the player to have both Minthara and Halsin the party! I wish there was a way to spare Minthara's life during Act I while siding with the Tieflings/Druids instead of the goblins. Do a long rest to remove silent spell and you will have a buggy Minthara in your party. Gather your party and venture forth! Act 1 - Spoilers I already know and have done routes with saving Halsin and Minthara by knocking her out as a temporary hostile opponent at the goblin camp while killing the remaining leaders. as soon as i step into the portal to leave, Minthara disappears. ADMIN MOD Killed leaders, knocked Minthara, Halsin won't leave . I killed the 2 goblin leaders, and killing Minthara then proceed to Act 2. " Minthara seems way more interesting and complex than Halsin, who has the personality of a sack filled with leaves and twigs. I killed Karlach, but Mizora insists she's still breathing? upvotes Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • Valens93 So now that it's possible to recruit Halsin and Minthara both in a good run (save the Tieflings and knock out Minthara while she's temporaily hostile in Goblin camp, as of hotfix 5) has anyone actually done it? I'm just curious if anyone has noticed any problems with it. As the title states: I was bummed to learn that you cannot recruit Minthara unless you essentially turn on the tieflings, and in turn lose a bunch of other party members. I read somewhere that they end up sharing Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • John_Bloodborne Thats your problem. In a long term perspective, you can Halsin or Minthara. She still has some comments and also approve/disapprove your decisions in cut scenes. Laez and shart are neutrally conflicted by this and will stay no matter who you chose. His dialogue is different if you already talked to Minthara. " “try it and I’ll gut them and cut your hands off, I don’t like to share Tav: "Minthara tell the one about the drow who married a drider. As some other comment here said, it's fan service to be completed. And there you go, that's how you can bug the game enough to keep all of your party Halsin then cheerfully stands, usually, near Withers. Previous exploits that allowed this to happen showed that they both occupy the same tent area in camp. Looks awesome! Love the wooden duck. Reply reply More replies. If you want Halsin in your party, you can only get Minthara via a method that keeps Karlach too. From what others have said Halsin should have left, but now they share a tent :/. This was a change made in the last patch to prevent Halsin and Minthara sharing a tent like they used to do. That doesn't affect anything gameplay-wise, it's just funny to see Minthara It would be really interesting if there was an option where you could avoid Minthara but still wipe out the goblins and save the grove. Have him wait in the room. My previous research before patch 5 had people saying you couldn't long rest after knocking out Minthara and grabbing her from the tower if I wanted Gather your party and venture forth! I've just done the shadow portal bit with Halsin, and now I have both Minthara and Halsin with me, in camp they stand togetherweirdly. And the twist about her ex being Sauron was incredibly epic. Sazza will be ready to be saved again. The quest will also update properly this way like minthara was killed. He joined up and everything went back to normal. Also, some Act 3 camp spots don't have separate tents for them, but the "main" camp spot (anywhere in the city) they do have separate spots. All the Tieflings will make it safely to Act 2. With Minthara, Halsin will hang outside of Minthara's tent where his ought to be. Add a Comment. Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online. Dialogue with Minthara implies I can pretend to raid the Emerald Grove with her. If you try to fast travel back to the Act 1 region with Minthara in the party, she Image: Larian Studios via HGG / Justin Moniquette. Yes, and they sleep together. But yes, there’s no redemption or personal growth like you have with Astarion or Lae’zel. Comparisons between Halsin and Minthara prompt discussions on player preferences for party members. Halsin was at the party, enjoying the "stimulating company" of goblins and especially happy not to be in charge of the grove anymore . I dismissed a party member, and brought him into my party again. If you side with Minthara and slaughter all the Tieflings, you can romance her and wake up the following day in a sequence that requires you to pass a persuasion check. The devs didn't even have to put any effort into writing the romance between them because it pretty much writes itself. ADMIN MOD Minthara and Halsin in Patch 6 (no long rest?) Quest Help I've been planning a new good run to get Minthara and Halsin for a while now. A community all about Baldur's Gate III, the role-playing video game by Larian Studios. Halsin makes no mention of her after you recruit her. Either way, there should be a way to spare in Act I and then 4 - Go to the prison and free minthara (no need to save the halfings/gnomes yet) and fight your way out of moonlight tower (around the kitchen counter clockwise from the balcony is the safest way). If the goblin forces are defeated and Minthara is killed or knocked out, Halsin: I can only hope we still find time to vanquish the curse. Halsin represents the good path, while Minthara is very evil-aligned. So no idea, sorry. Modding will be your friend if you want them both. If you recruit Minthara the It depends on how you deal with Minthara. Anyone else with this bug? Note: Halsin is also in my camp and they share a tent but Halsin can be Baldur’s Gate 3 fans recently shared hilarious experiences after accidentally recruiting Minthara with Halsin in the party. But after saving Halsin, he The exploit that became canon when the Larian team made it a little bit easier allows you to defeat Minthara by knocking her unconscious. They're getting along famously. Recruiting Minthara: There is no way to recruit both Minthara and Halsin in the same party Now Halsin is in my camp and Minthara is waiting for me at the mountain pass. A few more interesting things occur when I bring one out in my party. Went about my business with the other goblin leaders, talked to Halsin, everyone's happy Tiefling party. Act 2 - Spoilers Hey friends, I manage to rescue Minthara and Halsin in the same Here are my ideas: Tav, Minthara, Halsin, and Gale or Tav, Karlach, Halsin, and Gale. Knocking out seems quite useless in general, might be made for Paladin oath or something. Players reflect on the impact of Halsin’s role in the overarching storyline and question the necessity of his presence The original plan was that you could only have Minthara or Halsin, not both; that particular tent is where either one would camp depending on whether you raided the grove or killed the goblin leaders. Talked to her, she instantly joined my party. Q&A. Halsin dies if returning to Act I Sure does Tieflings die if returning to Act I Sure do Minthara didn't disappear or poof when I attacked her! The mod isn't running. So the choice I have right now is, do the grove quest to keep Karlach and Wyll and possibly get a companion I'll most likely never use or not finish the quest to get Minthara. More Reference: [2] IGN, "Baldur's Gate 3: Minthara and Halsin's Factions," accessed August 2023. r/BaldursGate3. Finish the Halsin recruitment at Last Light. Changing Minthara recruitment was like altering half a line of code, since all of that was already in place with Sheep-thara method. Normally, you get Minthara before you complete that quest since you normally get to the tower before completing it. any ideas? Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • Aries_AyTx. She'll be knocked out, her state doesn't change once she's out cold. iczqtizmkyufgampgabcbekjrrifyprxdotnbptwrkzasuz