Frigate vs zoneminder. I ran zoneminder first.

Frigate vs zoneminder the one CPU in the laptop. Now I will install frigate and see how it works I just don't have a coral to help in the AI. ZoneMinder is a free, open source Closed-circuit television software application developed for Linux which supports IP, Compare frigate vs Zoneminder and see what are their differences. If that doesn't suit you, our users have ranked more than 25 alternatives to ZoneMinder and 15 are available for Linux so hopefully you can find a suitable replacement. ↳ ZoneMinder 1. So, all of my automations and integrations are done through Frigate. It is best to run the container on a host running a Debian-based distribution for easier access to hardware components. I saw zoneminder as overkill for my needs. Frigate just does its job. However, Im using the same half-pci coral in unraid with frigate and it works without issues. Frigate set up with several cameras set to cat detection. Synology Surveillance Station. tater1337 Posts: 6 Joined: Thu Nov 17, 2022 2:22 am. A place for discussion of topics that are not specific to ZoneMinder. Uses OpenCV and Tensorflow to perform realtime object detection locally for IP cameras. But given the fact that I cannot find a coral usb in stock anywhere, I have detection turned off for now, just doing 24/7 recording. So I haven’t really figured out how to do it. I really really like the idea to offload the motion detection to iCloud+ and a high „women’s acceptance Great writeup. I use it for object detection and 24/7 recording. Docker volume mappings can be used to map these to any location on your host machine. After borking my Zoneminder install (by updating Arch) and spending hours trying to get it back, I began considering alternatives. So looking to switch to one of the open source solutions thats well integrated with HASS. The best Shinobi alternative is ZoneMinder, which is both free and Open Source. Use of a Google Coral Accelerator is optional, but strongly recommended. However, I will say they are not apples-to-apples products. I also record 24/7 via frigate to a HA network share, I've not needed to watch back hours of footage yet and agree the playback UI could look nicer but I can't imagine it being a problem on the rare chance I need to view a load of footage Vs just the motion clip. I've been toying the idea of making the switch to BI. Explore solutions for the Frigate object mask not working, including troubleshooting tips and common pitfalls. Recent commits have higher weight than older ones. I realize this is a new project, so things will come in time. Revolutionize your code reviews with AI. Open comment sort options Geez I dedicate 3 cores on a 8400T and those cores are at like 30%. It's old and dusty, One of the most solid ZoneMinder alternatives available is Frigate. Then over the last 6 months (with Frigate migrating to go2rtc and other changes between v0. Bluecherry - Bluecherry surveillance system Frigate - NVR With Realtime Object Detection for IP Cameras. It would nice for gethomepage. C Zoneminder - ZoneMinder is a free, open source Closed-circuit television software application developed for Linux which supports IP, USB and Analog cameras. viseron - Self-hosted, local only NVR and AI Computer Vision software. 0 USB and ZHA all running well. There are more than 25 alternatives to ZoneMinder for a variety of Go to ZoneMinder r/ZoneMinder Frigate uses go2rtc, I would setup the streams in frigate and then use the frigate go2rtc rtsp URLs in zm. It's just zm that doesnt work. I have been running Shinobi and ZoneMinder in parallel on the same server for a while now. ZoneMinder宝刀老了未？ Shinobi：我先老了吗？ Frigate：AI IoT时代的最佳选择; 总结：哪个NVR录影方案最适合你？ Synology Surveillance Station：买软件送硬件？ Add any particular hints or tricks you have found to help with your ZoneMinder experience. Just way less fussy than Shinobi IMO. New comments cannot be posted. motioneyeos - A Video Surveillance OS For Single-board Computers . NVR with realtime local object detection for IP cameras (by blakeblackshear) ZoneMinder is a free, open source Closed Blue iris is a superior nvr. I’m using zoneminder which is great, but the object detection does need quite a bit of setup and tuning. There are more than 10 alternatives to Shinobi for a variety of platforms, including Windows, Linux, Android, iPhone and iPad apps. ZoneMinder - Free. Frigate has the perfect balance of performance, reliability and simplicity. I still have a github issue opened on it. Ultimately, if you are comfortable using YAML configuration files and have a system already running Docker, Frigate is a great option. Then I unistalled it. Blue Iris, unlike iSpy, is a closed-source video surveillance software program. Frigate NVR Vs Zoneminder Comparison. Scrypted is running on portainer in Proxmox on the second thin client and is boring as hell as it just works now it seems. Zoneminder worked but seemed to have a few issues with the Doorbell camera. Setting up for work currently, 80 cameras going currently, works a treat with decent hardware Shinobi and Frigate. Question: What is your personal experience with ZoneMinder or Frigate in the last year, and what hardware do you use? In the ZoneMinder docs I see i3 and i5 are not recommended, but in UPDATE - I went with Frigate and love it. It's not free, so if you're looking for a free alternative, you could try Motion or MotionEye. nothing I try works - I can't even get a stream in VLC. I'd rather see my local regional formats everywhere. I'm trying to run ZoneMinder on a Raspberry Pi400 with a Reolink RLC-842A camera. I have more cameras on ZM than frigate right now. After a couple years I tried blue iris and that was the end of zoneminder for me. I notice he compares his package to ZoneMinder. 37. However, because Zoneminder would treat the streams as different cameras you’d be able to Get a Coral Accelerator and use Frigate. . I spent so long fiddling with the others to make them work, and it always felt like they were on the edge of falling over. (Also confirmed the same behavior in 1. Bluecherry - Bluecherry surveillance system (server application) . frigate - NVR with realtime local object detection for IP cameras ustreamer - µStreamer - Lightweight and fast MJPEG-HTTP streamer rtsp-simple-server - Also known as rtsp-simple-server. frigate vs Shinobi motioneye vs Zoneminder frigate vs viseron motioneye vs motioneyeos frigate vs scrypted motioneye vs MJPG-streamer frigate vs HASS-Deepstack-object motioneye vs Shinobi frigate vs Agent motioneye vs motion frigate vs docker-wyze-bridge motioneye vs iSpy. 5") - - VMs/Jails; 1 xASUS Z10PA-D8 (LGA 2011-v3, Intel C612 PCH, ATX) - - Dual socket MoBo; 2 xWD Green 3D NAND (120GB, 2. Frigate Configuration: Edit your Frigate configuration file to include the ONVIF parameters for your camera. Frigate was added some while ago, but the guy who did all the work didn't finish it. I used Zoneminder for many years to capture and display my home CCTV cameras. The best Linux alternative is Shinobi. However, it works fine with Blue Iris (yuk). Alternatively, I've been hearing a lot about Frigate NVR but haven't really dove in to it myself yet. motioneye - A web frontend for the motion daemon. I'm a BSD & Linux only user - so, as much as I like the features of BlueIris, it's not an option. So I want to make the decision dependant on what integrates better with Home Assistant and as far as I can see there is an integration existing for Zoneminder but not for Motioneye, is that correct? What Moving from Zoneminder with ZMNinja app to Frigate NVR. TLDR: ZoneMinder < Frigate, also AI Object detections is the future on CCTV, in case you need a Frigate notification tool at the bottom there is the script which i quickly wrote. No matter what, I know it Premium Services for Frigate NVR. Cameras configured to output H. The next release looks like it'll have some improvements on that front so I'm hopeful soon(tm). Quick question: I am using Zoneminder for my "primary" NVR, and I am using sub streams to trigger the full-resolution streams. CPU detection should only be used for testing purposes. dev to support a widget that shows which cameras are online and functioning. viseron. You will also see a few files alongside the database file while Frigate is running. Frigate is an open-source NVR (Network Video Recorder) that focuses on real-time AI object detection. ZoneMinder . But I do currently still use the camera DVR that feeds streams to Frigate. First, if you are only interested in event recordings, stick with Frigate, Scrypted NVR is 24/7 with event scrubbing. Compare Zoneminder vs frigate and see what are their differences. The Old System I am using the same Dahua I've been running Zoneminder for about a year now and after the first few week of teething issues it's been pretty good. s Two in one afternoon?! @Zack-45Drives is back again, sharing his thoughts and experience with Frigate NVR. Post by tater1337 » Sun Feb 25, 2024 4:45 pm. I really love Frigate combined with it's Home Assistant capabilities. Explore how Frigate utilizes GHCR for efficient container management and deployment in your projects. motioneyeos - A Video Surveillance OS For Single-board Computers Explore the technical differences between Frigate NVR and Zoneminder for video surveillance solutions. 5 posts • Page 1 of 1. Rebuilt it maybe twice. Agent has a unified user interface that runs on all modern computers, mobile devices and even Virtual Reality' and is an app. Now just to figure out some more of the config stuff and should be solid! There's ZoneMinder. For my personal use, It blows Agent DVR (Which I had been using for several months) out of the water. 264 video and AAC audio will offer the most compatibility with all features of Frigate and Home Assistant. H. version: '3' services: zoneminder: container_name: zoneminder restart: always image: dlandon/zoneminder network_mode: bridge privileged: false shm_size: 1gb ports: - '9001:80/tcp' - '9002:9000/tcp' environment: - TZ=Europe/London - PUID=1005 - PGID=1000 - Customer Support: Zoneminder vs Blue Iris. robvdl Posts: 2 Joined: Thu Mar 16, 2023 7:19 pm. Explore the Frigate card GitHub repository for advanced integrations and customizations to enhance your Frigate experience. Frigate is superior for object detection and effortlessly integrates with HA. I tried BlueIris a few months ago and if i remember right it needed waaaay more resources than Frigate. Soon enough frigate will be subscription based if you want a half decent object detection. I have both cat and dog listed, however it seems frigate is so smart it does not record the various other Post here to ask any questions about hardware suitability, configuration in ZoneMinder, or experiences. I had been running Blue Iris on a laptop PC for years, but switched it over to the FreeNAS system because (a) it's already running 24/7 and (b) it's got eight CPUs vs. I've got 4 outdoor cameras installed now with two more to put up and I'm shopping for doorbell cams with rtsp. 4 xSamsung 850 EVO Basic (500GB, 2. Frigate Ghcr Integration. Comparison: Frigate vs. Activity is a relative number indicating how actively a project is being developed. 10:04am 4. Frigate provides an HTTP API for interacting w/ the software. 265, and they support a limited number of H. The HA integration was simple for getting at the cameras but I never really got more out if it than that. 40) The tldr is that it seems passwords are being handled differently, and that special characters aren't being URI escaped correctly (my guess. Although frigate can do some of what the camera can do, with a nicer mqtt Frigate utilizes advanced streaming technologies to optimize the display of camera feeds on the dashboard and single camera view. Support Have been using Synology NAS with surveillance station for a while. Our crowd-sourced lists contains more than 10 apps similar to Frigate NVR for Linux, Self-Hosted, Windows, Mac and more. Frigate effectively balances this load by utilizing the CPU for motion detection and delegating object detection tasks to the Google Coral accelerator. Too immature. Why I chose Frigate by Zack Perry Frigate is an Check out frigate. IOwait Frigate vs Zoneminder. That is a very basic fundamental thingy. 265 profiles. Bluecherry - Bluecherry surveillance system (server application) Hi, I’m using the community version of Zoneminder - my QNAP Docker Compose yaml is as follows. 265 has better compression but less compatibility, as only Chrome 108+, Safari, and Edge can play H. The setup processes for Frigate and Blue Iris are entirely different, Question: What is your personal experience with ZoneMinder or Frigate in the last year, and what hardware do you use? In the ZoneMinder docs I see i3 and i5 are not recommended, but in some of the forums I've read that this is outdated info due to how old i3 and i5 handles core counts. Did you build the docker image and added any extra paramenters to import the coral device? The number of mentions indicates the total number of mentions that we've tracked plus the number of user suggested alternatives. None of my cameras just worked at first. cwoodhouse (c wood) blakeblackshear/frigate. Seems to be specifically built for detecting objects, while all other functionality is secondary. A complete and local NVR designed for Home Assistant with AI object detection. Zoneminder is a pretty solid setup for IP security cameras, and the zmninja app is really nice too. I have used ZM for 10 years. I'm hoping the recording management gets better with Frigate. It was designed for CCTV cameras and I used it back in the day. How do you deal with accessing frigate remotely since it doesn't seem to have user accounts and login feature? After 8+ years of using Zoneminder I'm looking to move to something less resource intensive and have tested Frigate with a USB Coral device and really like how little cpu this The best Frigate NVR alternatives are ZoneMinder, Shinobi and Yawcam. So, I researched alternative ways to see all my cameras in HA - ZoneMinder, Webrtc and other solutions out Thanks Shep. Zoneminder has been fantastic for that, aside from motion detection getting wonky every so often. Os-nvr is pretty barebones but has object detection through doods. After that each user will have to edit the configuration file. agent - An open and scalable video surveillance system for anyone making this world a better and more peaceful place. Frigate is running on a Dell Optiplex 3050 MFF, i5-7500T, 16GB of RAM, OS is on a 1TB NVME, records are going to a 2TB 2. 36. Zoneminder setup Vs Wyze cameras. The Blue Iris user interface is far superior to Zoneminder and is constantly updated by the developers. Zoneminder - ZoneMinder is a free, open source Closed-circuit television software application developed for Linux which supports IP, USB and Analog cameras. I use blue iris when I want to look at footage. The main arguments seem to be: Zoneminder is mature, reliable and easy to set up, but development is stalling and fragmented, hasn’t matured to new technologies and similar stuff. Full disclosure: I've never used zoneminder, so I can't speak to the differences. This way only go2rtc is hitting the cams and then zm and frigate are pulling their streams from go2rtc. Personally I use Zoneminder as a stand alone server (well VM) for 12 cameras covering my From that perspective, using a tool like Frigate will most likely be a better Blue Iris alternative than Synology Surveillance Station. 04 3 LTS. Used with Zoneminder for most of last year but switched to Scrypted in December. /config: Used to store the Frigate config file and sqlite database. Maybe there is a good description or video for this (or a similar application) that I could The Frigate docker compose is configured with network:host, everything combined means I'm not sending traffic through my router. Bluecherry - Bluecherry surveillance system (server application) zoneminder aprenda como instalar uma central de comitoramento CCFTV com o zoneminder instalando no ubuntu Server 22. Boost productivity and code quality across all major languages with each PR. Canal BoraParaPratica: @borapara Frigate NVR web interface in debug mode showing tracked objects - screen taken from Frigate docs . Blue Iris offers a paid license, and Zoneminder is a free open-source option for customers. I have been running frigate forever, but tried scrypted cause of it felt a bit faster with less lag, but that could just be some placebo. camera detection (movement, person, vehicle) and various rules like tripwire, direction detection, zones, etc. This allows it to be a paid product, thus having the capital Frigate NVR Vs Zoneminder Comparison. The framework for autonomous intelligence Design intelligent agents that execute multi-step processes autonomously. But no matter what I do, I cannot get ZoneMinder to show the camera as running. This has been made clear. Frigate employs a sophisticated video pipeline that begins with the Zoneminder and Frigate both use ffmpeg to decode video, and both have ways to supply camera specific settings. Looking for CCTV/NVR recommendation (Frigate, Shinobi, iSpy, BlueIris, Zoneminder, etc) Frigate can be installed as addon if you are using home assistant OS or via plugin if using docker. It worked, but not without a lot of care and feeding. I have HA on a Linux Pc, Sonoff 3. My Frigate Config – here’s an example from the main “driveway” camera feed, this is the one I want to be montoring & ntoified about most. Both are nice and differ from eachother. Frigate NVR is similar to Blue Iris, Zoneminder or Shinobi. Awesome info! I’ve been flip flopping from Zoneminder + deepstack, then shinobi, then Zoneminder docker by dlandon (using GPU) - had a SQL issue so tried Shinobi with tensorflow plugin (not as easy to grab the video), and now back to dlandon’s Zoneminder docker using YOLOv4 utilizing GPU. Snapshots but no recordings. By the way, do you have a current source of coral usb sticks? Just wanted to take some time and rave about Frigate NVR. While I still use Spectrum for constant recording, I rarely look at it anymore because Frigate captures people so reliably. I would like to record and see what animals come and eat. This could include Linux, Video4Linux, CCTV cameras or any other topic. There is a lot to learn here. ZoneMinder is a bundle of open-source software that offers a complete surveillance solution Use Frigate or deploy Shinobi as a custom-app, there’s instructions on the old forums for Shinobi. 2 posts • Page 1 of 1. Is there a way to do this with Frigate since it's only looking for a 300x300 sample anyway? I have looked over the docs for the project and I thought I saw it mentioned but I don't see a way to actually implement it. I’ll try it today. Do you have experience for or against this? I've got a small network of IP cameras at home and have been using Zoneminder integrated with Home Assistant for the last year or so to monitor them. Explore the technical aspects of configuring Frigate for optimal performance and efficiency in your surveillance setup. x; ↳ ZoneMinder 1. Partly because I loathe windows, partly because it’s free. 42, and my rtsp streams broke. I use it to record one camera 24/7 low res and monitor two cams for motion on low res but capture high res videos on motion trigger. This image is how it is configured in BI. frigate - NVR with realtime local object detection for IP cameras . This gives a base set of images to work from after some time working. Shinobi is more feature rich and I believe a tad bit lighter than frigate. So it seems I'm really "supposed to" keep the names the same everywhere which is a bit of a bummer; is there a way to get the mse option without having the go2rtc section names matching exactly the camera section names? Frigate standalone works super smooth with no hiccups at all. With Frigate's local processing, there is no need to pay for your personal camera footage to be sent to the cloud for analysis. I actually currently run both, but motion detection is done entirely via Frigate (tagging is sent to BI via MQTT). Any suggestions on the source path please? Edit: this is the log from Blue Iris and the stream URLs I have tried in VLC and Zoneminder: I just upgraded from 1. Zoneminder is old and not particularly user friendly Shinobi is new, using new tech, but not software mature and has an over complicated menu system NAS CCTV works well enough but licences for additional cameras are a pain Not used a dedicated NVR before. Frigate has many settings, but compared to the archeology dig it takes to figure out most of ZM, frigate is all right there in the docs and specifically the config example. ZoneMinder：最輕量級，適合基本錄影功能，但是界面老舊，沒有新功能。 Shinobi：安裝簡單，但是設置界面不友善，功能有缺失。 Frigate：整合了AI識別和IoT觸發功能，適合智能家居，但是安裝繁瑣，對硬件要求高。 Frigate is the community favorite but it’s focus is more on motion detection events verses an always streaming and displaying approach. You mentioned MotionEyeOS but MotionEye in docker is a great and simple NVR tool as well. Hi all, I am just in the process to decide wether to use motioneyeos ort Zoneminder as my camera central and did a lot of Google research but the outcome is unclear. true. Frigate Object Mask Issues. Tried Shinobi. Background. There are many alternatives to ZoneMinder for Linux if you are looking for a replacement. I hadn't thought of snapshots for faces, but now that you've got me thinking it sounds like a differentiating feature I Frigate can use the coral and it’s running now in Docker on Debian. This Frigate docker tutorial provides another popular option. Yeah zoneminder is antiquated, built on a platform that is not highly performant and not designed around modern IP cameras. I am currently running zoneminder with 4 cams, but will transition to Frigate in the coming months to benefit of the integration with home assistant. Somewhat dissatisfied with the status quo of ZoneMinder, I set out to try a brand new security NVR - Frigate - and see if an NVR written specifically to integrate into Home Assistant could be used for more than just recording and viewing camera footage. I couldn't suffer through it these days and gave up. Either by entering shell and using nano, or enabling our VS Code Addon. ready-to-use RTSP / RTMP / LL-HLS / WebRTC server and proxy that allows to read, publish and proxy video and audio streams. The three most popular security camera DIY NVRs are ZoneMinder, iSpy, and Blue Iris. Speaking of customer support and other luxurious amenities that come with the two software, it is safe to say that both follow wildly different paths. ZoneMinder is described as 'Free video camera security application suite, designed for low cost DIY video security including commercial or home CCTV, theft prevention and child or family member monitoring including nanny cam applications' and is a Video Streaming app in the video & movies category. Growth - month over month growth in stars. Explore the technical differences between Frigate NVR and Zoneminder for video surveillance solutions. Our system must support at least 10 cams (several 4k, al least one is vehicle license read quality), a mix of WIfi and wired, rtsp & onvif support, audio, motion detect, zoom. The object recognition of frigate is outstanding. Shinobi - :peace_symbol: :palestinian_territories: Shinobi CE - The Free Open Source CCTV platform written in Node. Development may have stalled in July of 2023. I configured motion just to save event frames to a file structure, and not much else. 1 Like. What are you using for your surveillance capturing? Anything different? Feel free to create your own topic, and share your experience. It’s super lightweight and I love The number of mentions indicates the total number of mentions that we've tracked plus the number of user suggested alternatives. I see, I found an older video for Zoneminder, but unfortunately I’m a complete beginner. I am using object detection for people and have not yet had a false positive or false negative. Another thing is that my cameras have ZM and Frigate accessing it. Also the lack of package detection on It appears that it's been a while since the last update to ZoneMinder. The number of mentions indicates the total number of mentions that we've tracked plus the number of user suggested alternatives. The system intelligently switches between modes based on network conditions, player errors, and specific features like two-way audio. A lot of the pro-shinobi posts I see are from it’s developer, so taken with a grain of salt. Shinobi is modern, less fragmented but The best Synology Surveillance Station alternatives are ZoneMinder, Shinobi and Yawcam. I'm running Frigate on an NUC i5 and like 10-15 more containers without Coral and I really can't complain. 1 Like As someone who used zoneminder extensively in the past. Scrypted and frigate - frigate is very integrated with HA and has an incredible ZoneMinder Google Coral Edge TPU Frigate HomeAssistant. Locked post. All processing occurs locally on your devices, meaning no camera feed gets out of your home. Previosly, I built a home security camera system using ZoneMinder. Frigate takes care of garbage collecting old assets. Specify the object types to track, define a required zone for autotracking activation, and include the preset name you created. 13), I started to hit many of the common issues (glitching, frame drops, image distortions and audio sync problems) that others have described. motioneyeos - A Video Surveillance OS For Single-board Computers Shinobi - :peace_symbol: :palestinian_territories: Shinobi CE - The Free Open Source CCTV platform written in Node. Questions, comments and curiosities, as always, are welcomed. Frigate excels at AI object recognition and integrating it in I just wanted to thank the devs. TBH none of them had a major effect other than sub streams coming up I was wondering if anyone has tried all of these: Frigate vs Doods vs BlueIris vs Deepstack with Google Coral for object detection and could give us a summary of Pros / Cons for each of them ? nickrout (Nick Rout) February 1, 2022, 5:04am 2. The UI3 timeline Shinobi vs Zoneminder frigate vs motioneye Shinobi vs Bluecherry frigate vs viseron Shinobi vs agent frigate vs scrypted Shinobi vs motioneye frigate vs HASS-Deepstack-object Shinobi vs motioneyeos frigate vs Agent Shinobi vs moonfire-nvr frigate vs docker-wyze-bridge. Frigate NVR vs ZoneMinder I think the best way would be to just have 2 connections per camera 1 to Scrypted and 1 to Frigate. Self-hosted, local only NVR and AI Computer Vision software. You will be able to fine tune your model with the images you have uploaded and annotated up to 12 times with your annual subscription. It not only works with Frigate inside a container but also with a natively installed MotionEye. Use of a Google Coral Accelerator is optional, but highly recommended. There are eight alternatives to Agent DVR for a variety of platforms, including Linux, iPhone, iPad, Self-Hosted and Mac apps. video/Shinobi Install Intructions / Documentationhttps://docs. If you just want to know if something works with ZoneMinder or not, please check the Hardware Compatibility sections in the forum, and the Wiki first. Frigate Card GitHub Integration. Has anyone used both and what do you like about one versus the other? Archived post. Either way if you chose to use look into hardware acceleration but if you have a newer CPU you will be fine. It offers most if not all important features, is easy to install, and is user-friendly. Frigate offloads For what it's worth, I've been running Blue Iris in a VM on FreeNAS for several months, and it seems to work fine. This strategy allows Frigate to manage multiple camera feeds without overwhelming the Coral, ensuring efficient operation. Frigate NVR VS Synology Surveillance Station. CodeRabbit: AI Code Reviews for Developers. I started working on this when I got tired of my Arlo cameras always giving false positives or not recording at all. Home Assistant plugin? I know lots of users prefer to do video in Home Assistant using Frigate, but I have gone down another path and I'm using Zoneminder for my security setup Frigate vs MotionEye - Recommended NVR that supports network storage for continous recording . Shinobi Home Pagehttps://shinobi. The frustrating thing is I know that controls through ONVIF work as Frigate could I played with ZoneMinder and Shinobi a long while back (both can integrate with OH, ZoneMinder through an add-on and Shinobi through REST API calls). I just wanted motion detection on multiple "internet cams" on my wireless network. I just started using the HKSV with an Amcrest doorbell and turrent camera. Blue Iris. Setup & Configuration Process – Frigate vs. Images are imported to Roboflow and annotated with cat1, cat2. === Links ===Show NotesComing soon, just behind this week. I had tried ZoneMinder but it would keep my fan at full speed! MotionEye only causes the fan to spin up when recording motion. Its a breeze, works out of the box with a simple yaml configuration file, and has support for really stellar object recommendation if you want it. Frigate vs. With features such as object detection, motion detection, face recognition and more, it gives you the power to keep an eye on your home, office or any other place you want to monitor 29 votes, 10 comments. 11 and v0. I have looked at and installed zoneminder. Just sharing some thoughts here (these are my personal views only, both (Agent DVR and ZoneMinder) are free dvr software and have put lots of efforts in prov Ditto with Frigate, with 4K clips viewable with the Frigate HA integration UI and lower res substream viewable live; Available in the UK so personally, I focus more on integrations into HA that support the camera’s functionality. I google this question and get a lot of conflicting advice. My DVR basically continuously records and acts as a backup. Our crowd-sourced lists contains more than 10 apps similar to Synology Surveillance Station for Linux, Self-Hosted, Mac, Windows and more. scrypted - Scrypted is a high performance video integration and automation platform I just made the switch from Frigate to Scrypted. Zoneminder on the other hand is just a much more developed and dedicated surveillance NVR. Frigate NVR is an open sourced camera feed view w/ build AI processing. So this is my journey of testing various NVR opensource softwares, a few years ago i decided Not sure if it will stick if i do a "docker restart zoneminder", pretty sure i'll have to redo it when i "docker rm zoneminder". If you choose Zoneminder, you will soon deal with technical issues with the older design without customer support. The two places where ZM trumps over Frigate today is better Webui and Zmninja. iSpy - Agent DVR (" runs in a docker container") but looks promising. Zoneminder can do it with linked monitors, but your interface is then cluttered with both Zoneminder - ZoneMinder is a free, open source Closed-circuit television software application developed for Linux which supports IP, USB and Analog cameras. Because if you do chose to use frigate and As a 3 year Zoneminder user who is considering switching to Blue Iris, why/what makes you say ZM isn't the answer? I'm genuinely curious. However I prefer Frigate 阅读全文: 【贵价vs免费】私人IP-CAM录影系统NVR 实测对比 Synology Surveillance / ZoneMinder / Shinobi / Frigate. Now that I've deployed Frigate, zoneminder records 24/7 with Frigate for notifications/indexing for notable events. Frigate can't yet handle retention based on available disk space. We will look at some of the key differences between Frigate vs. From my research Zoneminder, Bluecherry, or Shinobi seem to be the best fit for this kind of setup. Frigate. Frigate Configurations Explained. Stop reviewing shadows and wind and start reviewing detections that matter. Dataset is generated. Come on Frigate is a very close second and getting there. I just installed it a couple days ago on home assistant and wow. that's 3 1080p and one 2k camera using zoneminder Frigate NVR Vs Zoneminder Comparison. 摘要节点. Trying out Frigate (currently on zoneminder). If the native environment had some kind of issue, why isn't Motion affected? Viseron is a self-hosted NVR deployed via Docker, which utilizes machine learning to detect objects and start recordings. (normally I run about 8 cameras) then Frigate would revert back to only showing the jsmpeg option alone. However, one caveat is that going through events or footage is quite a hassle sometimes and may leave you with the feeling that you are not I can't add it to my existing Zoneminder setup. Sign in to your account. I wrote my own viewer using php. I just started using Scrypted last night and man was it stupid simple for HomeKit. I've read Zoneminder does it all, but the interface is terrible, and has a complicated setup (I can deal with a complicated setup if this is the best option). I've tried everything: zoneminder, shinobi, xeoma, ispy, AgentDVR. HASS-Deepstack-object - Home Assistant custom component for using Deepstack object detection Frigate is nice. Would love some feedback on this - was going to install Frigate, but see that it needs Zigbee2MQTT. If you ever need any help, Frigate+ is available and for a modest price will help Frigate - Appears too tightly enmeshed with google. Nothing says Beta like having to write your config changes to a text file inside the docker and restart the Frigate system. Aiming to mostly replicate the build from @Stux (with some mods, hopefully around about as good as that link). The object detection does work with coral and does not require a subscription to the NVR; use MQTT. Any compatible model that a user may find works better than the current built in model is able to be used in frigate, and this won't change. x; ↳ Mobile Apps and Event Server; ↳ Docker; ↳ ZoneMinder Distributions; ↳ ZoneMinder Translations; using Frigate thinking it is "the s**t" while the dedicated NVR would do a better job The cost of the dedicated NVR is not a problem Share Sort by: Best. I instead went with motion. I've been using zoneminder for a few years and have switched to frigate. Shinobi vs. 5") - - Boot drives (maybe mess around trying out the thread to put swap here too ZoneMinder Shinobi iSpy BlueCherry Motion MotionEye Monitor Frigate ContaCam DW Spectrum In the end, I installed a trial of BlueIris and ended up liking how simple it was and the "it just works" factor enough to purchase a license. The issue that I had was artifacting with Reolink. The Coral will outperform even the best CPUs Setting up video surveillance can be quick and straightforward, especially with solutions like ZoneMinder, which we have covered in our ZoneMinder Docker guide. Having some Linux experience is a huge help but after the initial install everything can be done through the web interface. I'd recommend setting up Frigate on docker. Let Frigate's AI scrub your video How would you say this compares to Frigate? (And would it have a Frigate Card type integration perhaps for HA?) It may have been the same reason I didn’t use zoneminder, too heavy and too many options for my single office camera setup. 34. Thank you! The base price of frigate is free so thats a pro, but if you count the plus subscription (custom models), the frigate+ and scrypted would be around the same yearly price. No response Shinobi - :peace_symbol: :palestinian_territories: Shinobi CE - The Free Open Source CCTV platform written in Node. I weighed ZM vs iSpy for quite a while, and chose iSpy. Blue Iris and Zoneminder are old school NVRs with very mature feature sets, but not very new user friendly. I might finally look at moving my Zoneminder setup over to something natively using HA, in combination with blakeblackshear’s real time object detection. Introduction. Frigate runs as a Docker container; you can get the official compose file and tweak it according to your needs. Other great apps like Shinobi are Yawcam, Blue Iris, MotionEye and Frigate NVR. $70 one-time, for up to 64 feeds was a no-brainer. CodeRabbit offers PR summaries, code walkthroughs, 1-click suggestions, and AST-based analysis. But it’s a nerd task to get it running. ) Like the other guy said, Blue Iris is kinda the gold standard but is closed source and costs money, plus it only runs on Windows unfortunately. Zoneminder - ZoneMinder is a free, open source Closed-circuit television software application developed for Linux which frigate - NVR with realtime local object detection for IP cameras . Zoneminder was immediately out, Frigate is all around useless, shinobi’s UI is terrible, Blue Cherry has an inconsistent UI and Kerberos Agent made my camera frigate - NVR with realtime local object detection for IP cameras motioneye - A web frontend for the motion daemon. 28 to 1. Motion detection was not great. Blue Iris is the gold standard but it requires Windows and cost $70. Tried zoneminder first and it didn't work well, frigate is just start and forget about it, usually just open it in the browser just to check is ok like 2 or 3 times a week. Frigate can communicate directly with the cameras through VLAN 113, I can access Frigate remotely through 113 and other services (eg HA) communicate via 111 all using existing network configurations. That is incorrect, frigate has always supported using custom models. Blue Iris below. viseron VS frigate Compare viseron vs frigate and see what are their differences. It most likekly won't work. Only downside is that frigate doesn't have a mobile app. Have tried shinobi and zoneminder mainly, recommended zoneminder out of the two. Frigate is probably the easier to setup vs zoneminder. 5" HDD, OS is Rocky 9, there is a PCI TPU The number of mentions indicates the total number of mentions that we've tracked plus the number of user suggested alternatives. I want to call DeepStack whenever needed. I had tried it years ago but got back to it recently with some sketchy IP cameras. I've been a diehard zoneminder fan for years, but I really like the integration of frigate into home assistant. Reply Digital_Warrior I ran zoneminder first. They also have some motion detection and send feeds to a 3rd ftp store. Seems like i need to remove ZHA then add Z2MQTT and maybe reflash my Sonoff etc. On this page. Shinobi - :peace_symbol: : Zoneminder - ZoneMinder is a free, open source Closed-circuit television software application developed for Linux which supports IP, With Frigate+, you get a model fine tuned to your cameras for improved accuracy in your specific conditions. However, the per camera licensing cost is insane. Plus I've grown very accustomed to ZMNinja for montage view. JS (Camera Recorder - Security Surveillance Software - Restreamer It was a bit reluctant to leave Zoneminder behind, as it’s worked quite well for me for a long time, but I like Frigate’s cleaner way of handling the main stream and substream from camera - so you do detection on the low res and record high res. I have frigate in Home Assistant and it is neat to play with but isn't close to what UI3 web interface or the BI app can provide. JS (Camera Recorder - Security Surveillance Software - Restreamer . Sign in with Google Home Assistant, OpenHAB, Node-RED, ioBroker, MotionEye, ZoneMinder, Frigate, iSpy Agent, Kerberos Containerized (Docker) Camera Surveillance System with OpenCV (Re) Introduction to Home Assistant Auto-discovery Frigate uses the following locations for read/write operations in the container. Other. A mobile app would be nice, but isn't necessarily a deal breaker. frigate VS DeepCamera; frigate VS Zoneminder; frigate VS SynoAI; Sponsored. motioneyeos - A Video Surveillance OS For Single-board Computers frigate - NVR with realtime local object detection for IP cameras . If there is a list of required values for the app to start, I can make some modifications. We have a motion light outside and we feed the wildlife. cwoodhouse (c wood) May 7, 2021, 1:26pm 6. Yes I’ve tried lots of combination of substream and main stream between frigate, synology, and hass. I used to use Zoneminder when I had this setup. It would be nice to have object detection an integral part of ZM similar to how Frigate is approaching the problem. Guess who is leading? :) In a longer run, I basically have only one biggish complaint about Shinobi: date/time formats. Stars - the number of stars that a project has on GitHub. Reply reply Agent DVR is described as 'New advanced video surveillance platform for Windows, Mac OS, Linux, Raspberry Pi and Docker. Additionally, I record not only the events, but but also a 24/7 video. rlhwsg lmf dvw zyqugn qhp lurcs pxznys wcs limrmr wqga