Elmax vs vg10 Sep 26, 2021 · Mit Elmax wiederum kann man immerhin solche Sachen machen. the VG10, from the composition we see that VG7 has 1% less chromium, adds 1. While N690 is similar in its Bohler Uddeholm: M390, Elmax, N690 Carpenter: CTS-204P, Myodo: H1 Takefu: VG-10 Zapp: LC200N. . 25% tungsten, but loses 1. Jan 2, 2019 · I read (somewhere that I don't recall) that the CoS offers 150% of the edge retention of the VG-10 version and the 3G F1 provides 200% of the VG-10 edge retention. One such element is carbon. Mar 4, 2024 · Unveiling the Impressive Strength and Versatility of AEB-L Steel. Dec 16, 2019 · Elmax. The more chromium the more carbide is formed. So I think the better comparison here would be VG7 vs VG10. It's fairly easy to maintain a fine edge, it has great corrosion resistance, and IMO resists scratching better than VG-10. It contains more carbon, Chromium, and Vanadium hence offering better edge retention, corrosion resistance, and toughness. Compared to AISI 440C Steel, it offers excellent wear resistance, offers more strength, and is tougher. I am glad to see them moving past VG10 but I am really surprised they haven't moved into the PM steel realm with the F1. Even taking the time to sharpen it on the edge pro, and the using a broader final bevel angle all just resulted in the same thing--it would get casually shaving sharp, but you could dull it by slicing up a sheet of printer paper. So is the Spyderco Moran in VG-10. One of the main differences is the type of steel. VG 10 steel has a lot of different elements in its composition that help make it a very high end, desirable steel to a lot of bladesmiths and knife manufacturers. It is a tough steel and has excellent corrosion resistance. I think it is easier to sharpen than S30V. See full list on knifebasics. 5% cobalt. VG10 is not that tough from my use. The 420J2 is a low-carbon high chromium alloy steel and we are using that because of its strength and its almost corrosion-free properties. The only downside is that it is difficult to sharpen compared to other offerings with similar toughness, but this should not be a problem if you have good sharpening skills. It has the same ~1% carbon as 19C27 and 440C, but intermediate chromium content of 15%, whereas 19C27 has 13% and 440C has 17%. So rather than buying the CoS, I'll just throw a spare VG-10 version in my pack and call it good. S45VN is more corrosion resistant than both (really a 7). VG-10 can be manufactured with variations in chemistry, resulting in varying properties. Carbon and tool steels (chromium content less than 13%) It is good, it is comparable and in some ways better than VG-10 and S30V. Which are noticeably below Elmax for toughness. r/knives Mar 22, 2014 · There not the biggest steel mill in Japan but they are the creators of one of the most prominent high end stainless steels in the world, V Kin (Gold) Ten or VG10. Damaststahl: Damaststahl ist ein Verbundwerkstoff, der aus verschiedenen Schichten von Kohlenstoff- und Edelstahl besteht. May 23, 2020 · That being said I'd go with Elmax over VG10 if possible, although I think most folks would be well served by a VG10 knife (assuming that it's been properly heat treated). This makes it better than VG-10 steel in all aspects. But heck, I already accumulated a half dozen VG-10 F1s over the years. VG10 is mid-range steel that is affordable in terms of price, and corrosion resistance and is also easy to sharpen. Elmax= does not sharpen well and does not keep initial sharpness well and I just hate it. Edge retention is the ability of a knife to maintain cutting ability during cutting. I will be focusing on CATRA edge retention which measures abrasive wear of knives. Oct 12, 2022 · From looking at the Fallkniven website they dont even offer VG10 any longer so it looks like VG7 will be the base and COS will still be an option. The difference between VG10 steel and 지금은 가성비 좋은 중상급 강재 취급받는 154CM이나 VG-10도 출시 당시(1959년)에는 슈퍼 스틸로 평가받았다. Reply reply More posts you may like r/knives. Jun 8, 2020 · S45VN leads in edge retention (580), followed by S30V (254) and S35VN (190). Let's start with lamination: this means that there is a core of good and hard knife steel, laminated in between two layers of softer stainless steel. Vs. Shun (KAI, ZT, Kershaw) has a good history of numerous steels & excellent HT procedures. Dec 15, 2011 · My limited experience with Elmax has been with the MT13 mule. Apr 19, 2022 · 3G steel is perfect knife steel because it offers a good balance of hardness, toughness, corrosion resistance, and wear resistance. Jan 30, 2010 · VG10 and Elmax are the worst steels (in my opinion and experience) VG10= Hyped as superior to steels like aus8 and 154cm. Let’s take a look at how it compares to a few key steels such as 440C, D2, S30V, M390, and VG10. I expected VG10 to have somewhat less carbide than it has. An like ELMAX, it's still a very tough steel at even 60. Not as good as Elmax or S45VN. Both VG-10 steel and 440C steel offer the same level of corrosion resistance and edge retention. Additionally it can be heat treated with varying methods resulting in varying properties. The F1 is made from laminated CoS steel, and the F1 Pro is made from laminated Elmax steel. 3g is a not the name of the steel used rather it's a proprietary Laminate with two softer pieces of vg2( a low carbon stainless much like 420j2) for added ductility and strength Oct 29, 2021 · VG10 vs VG-Max VG max vs other steels VG Max vs VG 10 steel Shun VG Max steel is an improvement of VG-10. Elmax vs D2 Jun 29, 1999 · Fallkniven seems to introduce new steels every few years, but I never had a problem with the VG-10 in my F1. However, VG10 looks closer to 440C than it does 19C27. In the context of a knife this would be chipped edges or broken knives. Feb 20, 2015 · Elmax > LAMCos > VG10 A quick google will tell you LAMCos gets you similar toughness to 154CM, 440c, etc. I find the steel to be a good overall performer like VG-10. Heat treatment is such a critical factor with knife steel that I should put "assuming it's been properly heat treated" in my signature line to save time typing. Feb 13, 2023 · I know that the F1 was made in VG10 steel for the last 20 years, but now they changed the steel to VG7. 1 of 2 is a great hunting knife. Like ELMAX, it does a great job holding an edge, but it performs really well across the board. : 61rc Elmax Toughness Test, Elmax knife abuse Das VG10-Laminat von Fällkniven sollte (!) also eigentlich mindestens genauso viel aushalten. Die Schichten werden durch Schmieden und Falten zu einem einzigartigen Muster und Textur geformt. 05% of carbon in VG 10 steel, which helps improve its hardness and makes it a tough type of steel. Thread starter Sparky22; Start date Jan 19, 2018; 1; 2; Next. I wish that spyderco (my favorite knife company + bark river) would quite using it as their main staple steel. Mar 17, 1999 · Title says it all, what is the consensus on elmax vs the more commonly used stainless steels like s30v, s90v, 154cm, vg10, etc ? Is elmax a "super steel"? I haven't come across much discussion or product using this steel. The addition of tungsten probably adds to edge holding (maybe Larrin can speak to that) but VG-10 is tough, stain resistant, holds an excellent edge and is easy to resharpen. Whether you’re a professional chef, a survival enthusiast, or an avid collector, understanding the unique properties of AEB-L steel is vital for making informed decisions and ensuring top performance. Oct 9, 2022 · Elmax vs VG10. Due to Elmax having a higher hardness level than VG10 steel the steel wins over VG10 in terms of edge retention, toughness level and wear resistance. Apr 15, 2014 · The F1 steel is VG10 - an “old” steel type that many new knife advertisements and reviews might lead you to believe is inferior in real-world extended use to the likes of Elmax, M390 and so on. Elmax - 7|6|7|4 - 344 TRC. S35VN is tougher than both (really closer to a 6). I've used Elmax and VG10, and Elmax is noticeably tougher. Jun 22, 2014 · S35VN is usually closer to ELMAX or CPM-154, where VG-10 is usually closer to 154CM. Apr 11, 2024 · Non-powder steel, slight upgrade to 440C/VG-10/ATS-34; Good corrosion resistance, decent toughness, modest hardness; Comparable to 440C and VG-10; Elmax has an advanced formula, and the result May 13, 2022 · VG 10 Steel Composition. S35VN and S45VN are easier to sharpen than S30V. I own some (pretty) knives in these steels and I find them as functional in terms of edge holding, sharpening behaviour and cutting as F1 VG10. Einige der bekanntesten Edelstahlklingenstähle sind VG-10, 440C und AUS-8. Note that some tests show similar edge retention between the 3, close to ELMAX. You can have really good VG10 & you can have sub standard VG10. 2021년 현재는 대충 S30V부터 Elmax나 M390 정도를 슈퍼 스틸의 기준으로 취급하는데 이것도 사람마다 달라서 종합적 밸런스를 중시할 것이냐 칼날 유지력을 Jan 4, 2015 · Better wear resistance and I once bought an Elmax knife that wouldn't hold an edge at all until I removed a bunch of metal from it. Usually we go for strong low/medium carbon stainless steel for the outer layers and add VG10, Cobalt-Special or Super Gold Powder Steel as a center steel. AEB-L steel is revolutionizing the world of blades. Toughness is a measure of how much resistance a steel has to fracturing. Aug 21, 2017 · Bark River Gunny Elmax vs Cruwear. Fallkniven claim that VG7 ''keeps the sharpness better than most and is a little stronger''. Jul 8, 2023 · N690 steel is a high-quality stainless steel with properties that put it in the same league as some other well-known knife steels. com Oct 19, 2021 · Toughness vs Edge Retention. Aus eigener Erfahrung kann ich allerdings sagen, dass die Schneide meines WM1 3G mehr verträgt als die des F1/VG10Lamn. N690 vs 440C: 440C steel is a high carbon stainless steel often used in knife making. VG-10 steel has added Cobalt and Vanadium elements in its composition. There is approximately 1. I have used it for mostly kitchen chores over the last 9 months, but also for Jul 9, 2021 · A D2 knife will hold an edge longer than a VG 10 knife. CoS vs VG10. 440C vs VG10. LAMCos commands a premium over normal VG10, so I'm going to guess it's tougher. tpdjjuyl mbudh hcbnc cyhxh dqv codrf vvqs qrclppm nuyvm yqr czlz zrxrs ihe tigjj mrzyux