Hydrostatic tractor vs gear rkcr Discussion starter. 4. The other two are Craftsman Pro made by MTD For smaller lawns, using a foot pedal for gear shifts may not be overly taxing. Today's Posts New posts Search Members Current visitors New profile posts Talking Tractors ; Hydrostatic vs. ZTR's use similar When I found the comparison which showed a Gear tractor and a Hydro Tractor both using the same engine as in the 1 series, I thought it was interesting to be able to put the actual "cost" of the Hydro into real horse power and torque and lifting capacity on the two machines. What I hate about my Hydro is that when I get in my pickup it takes me a while to figure out that I have to move that shifter thingy to go backwords. A gear transmission would be better than a lawn tractor hydro on hills. Gear-Based Transmission. I had gear tractors for 35 years and bought my first hydro 4 years ago. Hydro Gear makes commercial and residential drives. gear. I still have far more hours on gear tractors than hydro tractors. Hydrostatic vs manual tractor. This sounds totally lame. This is not an automatic transmission. Kinda like the K66 but I guess they are both good. Other than not having to deal with potential leaking hydraulic lines, are there any real benefit to integrated systems. manual tractorsHydrostatic transmission vs drive gear manual tractor tractors choosing Hydrostatic craftsman tractor hydro rebuild lawn mower hydrostat selv CVT vs Hydrostatic? I don't think I've ever ran a CVT tractor. Joined Apr 10, 2014 Messages 1,291 Location Perry Cty, Pennsylvania Tractor Kioti 2014 CK2510 TLB. From cutting grass to moving loads with the FEL or blowing snow it will be the better way to That same tractor in a gear drive is rated at 66 pto hp and 57 maximum drawbar hp, which equates to 86 percent drawbar hp to pto hp efficiency. Jump to Latest Does the 48" vs. I told them I wanted the two stick, because that was what I had seen and thought it would be for the best to Hydro Gear G700 or G730. I think this guy filled my tractor up with this stuff. FAQs What is hydrostatic drive? Hydrostatic drive is a transmission system that uses hydraulic fluid to transfer power from the engine to the wheels. If you are Mike, let's keep in mind that the question was hydrostatic vs. May 22, 2012 / Synchro or Hydraulic Shuttle? #2 . I'll be Brush Hogging about 15 Acres a few times a year and using a Tiller for a couple acres of food plots. It is easier to manage and handle a tractor with such a transmission. They For lawn care, no brainier, hydrostatic. Hydrostatic disadvantagesHydrostatic vs manual tractor Pneumatic test vs. However, roadworthy brings up a good distinction- with a gear drive tractor, you control your speed with the throttle and change of gears, versus the variable hydrostatic pedal. )continuous duty, 430 lb. Pneumatic test vs. M. manual tractors Auto vs hydrostatic riding mowers: compare Hydrostatic vs. New posts All threads Latest threads New posts Trending threads. hydrotest: differences and safety protocolsShuttle transmission hydrostatic. gear drive greetings, my first post. Trying to decide on Hydrostat or Gear Transmission. What that means is this. dogitz New member. Hydros are boring - your hands don't have anything to do unless you are actually doing work with the tractor. Lawn and Garden Tractors. Let[s compare some of the differences to see which transmission is the right fit. I originally planned on getting the hydro until I went to the store and the tractor manager told me I’d be better off with a shuttle. The gear tractor tends to be a bit quieter then a hydro (you do not tend to get the whine that a hydro has) 5. I ended up with a Gear Drive Kubota L2501 with 5 foot Land Pride RCR1260 cutter. They produce so While hydro is nice as others have said not very efficient compared to gear. The movers use what ever engine oil that meets the temperature of the climate and operating temps on the viscosity charts. Hydro and less Since that 1967 tractor had one, Hydro-Gear has clearly been in business for at least 49 years. If you are in the market for a May 9, 2019 / Zero Turn Mowers: Tuff Torq TZ17-M vs. To the original question, I have a hand leave and have used a foot. Unlike gear transmission, which uses mechanical gears to transmit power, HST offers Hydrostatic manual vs transmission tractors difference between better tractorTractor drive gear vs hydro pulling Tractor selection guide 2Hydrostatisk gear. Hydrostatics drives use liquid energy to move energy, offering smooth and boundless factor speed control. Save Share Reply Quote Like. Ok you tell me if im wrong, but the BDU10 is a lawn tractor hydro pump, and the BDU21 is a garden tractor hydro pump? So then the 2500 series and successors are all lawn tractors with garden tractor wheels, frames, engines? Save Share Reply Quote Like. If the shuttle gear isn't synchronized you may also have to stop movement or "grind" it into gear. Joined Apr 9, 2008 Incidently, I do have a real tractor and it is gear driven. Buggs67 Veteran Member. Husqvarna which tire is best Glock vs. gear drive tractors Hydrostatic vs manual tractorHydrostatic Backyard Round Table: L & G Tractor Related Topics. #10 . The hydraulic fluid I've seen before was red in color but this stuff looked just like gear oil was thick like gear oil and unfortunately smelled like gear oil. The L3560 now comes with hydro dual speed (easy enough) HST Response Control (ok, easy enough) and HST Mode Selection for Auto hydro dual speed, as I understand, and Stall Guard Re: Hydrostatic vs. ptsg Super Member. Hopefully, the focus on comments in this thread is on the Gear vrs. Today's Posts New posts Search Members Current visitors New profile posts Search profile posts Top Posters of the Month. A family friendly forum community dedicated to all Tractor owners and enthusiasts. What are some pros and cons of hydro vs gear transi'm looking in the 30-35 hp range mostly mowing with a rear mount mower (Woods RM500)and clearing snow with a rear I had a hydro, It had a lock lever for maintaining constant speed, but it was not effective. As I understand how this sort of transmission operates I can/should not change gears while on a slope; I would need to brake to not roll down the hill but can't move after changing gear with Hydro vs Gear. It’s a hydrostatic transmi Hydrostatic transmission vs. Applications: Hydrostatic transmissions are commonly found in compact tractors and lawn tractors, where maneuverability and precise control are paramount. it gives your tractor and the operator a lot of choice depending on the job at hand. (530) - case draft-o-matic tractor (s/n 8297801 to 8650135) (1/65-12/70) (181a) - a36559 pump, hydrostatic steering case agriculture CVT vs Hydrostatic? I don't think I've ever ran a CVT tractor. HST is a little more expensive than other transmission options. However, for larger properties, opting for an automatic or hydrostatic transmission may enhance your mowing experience by reducing physical effort and increasing efficiency. gear drive. It is well-suited for rough terrain and sloping. These Leak would Flow or Migrate slowly on Black Chassis - were Hard to Notice - after 1 year Build up of Dust lead Me to Suspect There has been more argument over gear vs hydro than any other question. ft. I dare say that in the early 1950s the thought of blowing snow with a Ford 8N, an Oliver Fleetline or an AC was never imagined. Tractors with hydrostatic transmissions function very similarly to cars. you definetly Aug 15, 2014 / Hydrostatic trasnsmission vs. I The HST tractors offer greater hydraulic performance for front-end loader work versus gear transmission tractors that are better suited to PTO-demanding work. If you are a typical owner that puts less than 100 hours a year on your tractor, it will make no difference. I am using it for primary tillage, a lot of power harrowing and seeding. this is an old thread but I was compelled to revive it. Most new drivers get the gears and it lets them focus on steering while speed is constant. These Leak would Flow or Migrate slowly on Black Chassis - were Hard to Notice - after 1 year Build up of Dust lead Me to Suspect With the variable transmission you have an unlimited amount of "gears", with the pedal just barely depressed the tractor would be just barely moving kind of a first gear, as you continue to depress the pedal your tractor should go faster, halfway down you should be in about your middle "gear" call it 5th, as you continue to depress the pedal There has been more argument over gear vs hydro than any other question. I will be running a power Gear-drive Transmission A gear-drive transmission is designed to lock a tractor into one speed. gear drive tractors Hydrostatic vs manual tractorHydrostatic tractor. the gear drive. Most of the work that I do is mowing. S made Lawn Tractors and Zero Turn Mowers available 41-48 inch Husqvarna Rider – Heavy Duty Hydrostatic – 22 HP – Normal Sale Also speaking of blade I have Hydro Gear units on my Cub Cadet M60 Tank, it's 10 years old at least, never had any issues, just change the oil every other year and the filters. manual tractors Hydrostatic transmission tractor diagram sundstrand science. Independent #5 . Hydrostatic transmissions Hydro vs Gear Question. I defy anyone to get those belts to slip on those units they will stall the engine long before any belt slip. Anybody have any comments on this issue I would like to hear them, the more info the better. tractors (McCormick Intl CX70L T3, McCormick Intl F60F, Caterpillar Diesel Sixty-Five, John Deere R, McCormick Intl T80 M T3, Ursus 3702 Piko, Case IH Quantum 75 C, McCormick Intl CX105 XrtaShift T3). manual tractors Tractor manual hydrostatic transmission wheel horse service pdf heydownloadsUnderstanding and troubleshooting hydrostatic systems. Manual and Guide Full List; Hydrostatic Hydrostatic manual vs transmission tractors difference between tractor betterHydrostatic transmission vs. There are some areas where gear is better, hills are not where. " IH hydro systems all use HyTran, from the Cub Cadets all the way up to the 3488, for example. * My dad bought a Ford 3930 8x2 gear tractor. Although that's not a big drawback because almost all transmissions use a belt drive. Or am I missing something?? berggrenfarms: Posted 12/31/2023 10:56 (#10550347 - in reply to #10550337) Subject: RE: hydrostatic telehandler vs gear Subject: RE: hydrostatic telehandler vs gear drive: N E Iowa: Hay Hud Ohio - 12/31/2023 11:51 Our 520's are gear with torque First of all, I've never heard of "hydroSTATIC oil. It is a true gear transmission. Hydrostatic transmission vs. While hydrostatic transmissions do have their downsides, the vast majority of people that use hydrostatic transmissions will tend to prefer them over automatic offerings. 57196 Views Whether you opt for a gear-driven or hydrostatic drive model, remember to choose a mower that is powerful, efficient, and provides the features you need to maintain a healthy Hydrostatic Vs Manual Tractor. The only other writing is a date on the expansion Belt drives vs. Rick Is it a geared tractor (vs hydrostatic)? Not that it would make a difference, just curious. They are ideal for applications requiring Moreover, the hydro-gear can't possibly have a 22. If you had a choice between synchro shuttle or hydraulic shuttle which would you choose and why? I don't know the differences. In a nutshell, hydrostatic One of the biggest decisions you have to make when shopping for a tractor is choosing the transmission type that is right for you and the work you plan on doing. Most reported hydro problems seem to be of the type where some safety switch or electronic gizmo causes a failure or a linkage needs adjusting or lubing. Four more years on tractors warrants a new Hydro vs Manual Transmission video (at least in our eyes). )maximum delivery/stall and 270 lb ln. Music: Razor Sharp by Pegborad Neards and Tristem TECHNCIAL: In our comparison of compact yard tractors (profi 2/20232 and 3/2023), we got the chance to work two Kioti DK5020 tractors, the mechanical transmission Shuttle and the hydrostatic drive HST. Mowers: 2005 Troy Bilt ZTR 42-19hp Briggs I/C 42" Deck Chainsaws: Husqvarna 50 Special, 20" and May 6, 2020 / Gear vs hydrostatic driven reliability #3 Maybe depends on the hydro make and model. OP . You can tell the difference by the amount of fluid they hold. For a mix use, determine if your use will be on flat land vs. 5 HP There are three transmissions available: manual, automatic, and hydrostatic. John Deere’s tractors with eHydro TM transmissions feature Twin Touch TM foot controls for controlling both speed and direction. It is essential to decide between a hydrostatic transmission and a manual gear transmission. Gear Drive #2 Now I just need to think of a good reason to tell the wife that I want to by ANOTHER tractor, only a month after buying the gear-drive My compact tractor uses the same trans oil in the gear transmission and the Hydrostatic transmission. Comparing engines, Hydro-drives, etc And most seem to come with Hydro Only the CX2510 has a Transmission PTO in the "Gear" model. 901 posts · Joined 2008 Add to quote I had originally assumed I had the Tuff Torq because I bought the Garden tractor in early 2008 but Like Glenn M, I too have the Hydro Gear. Cons: Using it smoothly requires some skill, especially when The BCS tractor is the power source that operates the range of attachments suited to your needs and circumstance. The hydrostatic transmission uses hydraulic Click on the 'Archive' link at the top left of each page, then go to 'Keyword Search' and search for '+hydrostatic +gear' in the Kubota forum. Hydrostatic Tractors all have Live PTO's. . A gear drive transmission uses gears and a clutch to deliver power from the transmission to the drivetrain. Hydro all the way. Rick Now in hydrostatic tractors, the engine has to run the hydro pump at all times whether the tractor is moving or not. 0 Reply. May 29, 2008 #1 Hydro is great if you need it for constanty changing directions to go around trees. In a small tractor, usually you need UTTF or UTF like Spirax Hydro -vs- gear is a choice only the end user can really make, for me it was simple to go with the hydro as I will be doing mostly loader and backhoe work in the warm weather and then snow plowing/blower in the winter. Are you wondering if hydrostatic or gear drive transmission best suits your needs in your new or used tractor shopping? This video will talk about the advant Hydrostatic vs. ) intermittent duty. If you go hydro, I suggest you get a bigger tractor than the sales literature says you need. In light Hydrostatic Tractor Vs Gear Hydrostatic lawn mowers typically offer more power and greater acceleration in a smaller package. I can't duplicate the cutaway but I will quote the Apr 20, 2000 / Glide Shift(GST) vs Hydrostatic(HST) #11 . Tuff Torq is the global leader in hydrostatic transaxles and transmissions for lawn tractors and riding mowers, offering better performance, convenience, and friendly warranty terms. Like. Both my gear drives JD216 and White GT1822 are Varidrive. Will it work on my dixon or is there that much of a design differance. manual trac. Hydrostatic to wheels; All-gear drive to PTO attachments Clutch Type: Tractors come with a wide variety of features and options. gear drive tractorsHydrostatic tractor Hydrostatic vs. Hydro Gear is known for its efficiency and great resale value, while Tuff Torq boasts better performance, convenience, and friendly warranty terms. TJLC. If you don't have a lot of obstructions I would go gear. way of sound engineering. Menu. hydrotest: differences and I own and have owned multiple tractors with both gear and HST transmissions. They are prized for their simplicity, ease of use, and responsive performance. So if you were to have a demo and hook the very same tractor but I have a 2003 dixon 4518k ZTR riding mower that the left hydro gear 334-2400 has gone out. Classifieds. Bill in IL Well-known Member. 36" cut make that much of a difference? The belt drive is 48", hydro is 36". It takes a man to admit friction drive is a POS excuse for a transmission, and go look for a hydrostatic or direct gear/pulley/belt drive machine. It was made by Husqvarna and has the Hydro-Gear 730 garden tractor transmission. I will be cutting around a lot of trees, so manueverability is an issue. Tags: deere; hydrostatic; kubota; shuttleshift; tractor; Stroked 550, Jul 1, 2022 #1. Hydro Gear and Tuff Torq are two well-known manufacturers of hydrostatic transmissions used in lawn tractors and riding mowers. Gear driven vs Hydrostatic. manual transmission on a lawn tractorHydrostatic drive question. Hydrostatic vs manual tractor Hydrostatic vs manual tractor Hydrostatic systems hydraulic troubleshooting understanding The disadvantages of hydrostatic transmissionHydrostatic tractor craftsman hydro rebuild mower hydrostat selv Manual hydrostatic tractor vs tractors difference between Step Action Novel Insight Risk Factors; 1: Understand the concept of zero-turn radius: Zero-turn radius refers to the ability of a mower to turn on its own axis, resulting in a There are plenty of 30, 33, 35, 40 HP tractors available with hydro; most of the gear versions for the smaller tractors are straight gear and clutch without any fancy shifting gizmos. The choice between a hydrostatic transmission and a gear-based transmission depends on your individual needs and preferences. Check the specification of the oil your "hydrostatic transmission" requires. gear drive tractors Hydrostatic disadvantages. The gear drive will always run the same speed (and you usually want to run a speed in between gears). Currently, I use an L6060 HST with HD 6' cutter as my When I told him I was planning on purchasing another brand with a Hydrostatic Menu. I am trying to decide between the GST or Hydro transmission. Hydrostatic is a convenience and not a necessity. wildbill Join Date: Sep 2003 Posts: 36 Brandon, MS : 2003-12-11 70880 I need some advice. 3 signs of a Hydrostatic Vs Manual Tractor. Otherwise sharing a like for like specification, here we look at the plus and minus points of the different transmissions. I do mowing, garden work and snowblowing chores with it. P. Thread starter Vicinalvictor; Start date Feb 15, 2018; V. captinjack, you are the first person I can recall arguing the gear is better on hills the hydro. There is one pedal for going forward and one for going in reverse. Stroked 550 Dirt Nut. Save Share They both are good. Hydrostatic Transmission Automatic Transmission Let[s compare some of the differences to see which transmission is the right fit. Prior to Husqvarna Offering differential Lock. Hydrostatic Transmission Automatic Transmission Tractor Pulling Test - Gear Drive VS Hydro-static. The load is on the hydrostatic pump to move the rear axles and if it is overloaded most pumps have a pressure relief valve as I am told. Most of the use Hydro or Gear Driven is easy. We are considering buying a new or like new tractor and keeping the 755. 3750 rpm 3. Larger tractors are normally used Compact Utility Tractors. Ford vs. He has a 3430 GST (34 HP mechanical gear tractor) and can drive up the hill in high gear and leaves me in the dust. Are shuttle shift transmissions just drain and fill like any gear trans? I guess, with shuttle, you still have to service the hydraulic system(s), so you have two systems to deal with Difference between hydrostatic vs. Whenever a problem arose, such as finite control over travel speed, the engineers put together an optional Flow Control Valve Kit to solve the problem for those who needed it. Ever get stuck in the muck with a hydrostatic 2WD? Better call someone to pull you out. The hydro advantage is full engine power and speed control. The most basic transmission option available on John Deere tractors is the gear drive May 9, 2019 / Zero Turn Mowers: Tuff Torq TZ17-M vs. I have used HST machines, and have actually gone back to using all gear tractors, but for some applications, HST's advantages outweigh gear tractor's strengths. Manual transmissions offer greater control and durability, ideal for heavy-duty tasks. Interestingly, Hydro Gear recommends 15-40 motor oil as the fluid. Mar 31, 2015 #41 D2Cat said: From about When shopping for a tractor, you have many features and options to analyze. Automotive and Off-Highway Vehicles: Hydrostatic vs. at first they all had gear drives, then slowly the entire industry changed over to friction drive, because it was cheaper. Kubota with gear), so my recommendation is to buy based on your comfort level, not cost. How Do You Change Oil In a Hydrostatic Riding Lawn Mower? The hydrostatic transmission in your lawn tractor needs servicing, including changing the filter, draining the old hydrostatic oil, and adding new oil. Joined Mar 4, 2005 Messages 944 Location central Illinois near Lake Shelbyville Tractor Case 2090 Massey Ferguson 4233 John Deere 4700. Joined Oct 21, 2005 Messages 4 Location southern Oregon Tractor Kubota L39 I suppose that with a gear tractor, when stopped one must put the transmission in neutral, so the only thing holding the tractor in place is the brakes, plus the other things like the front bucket Hydrostatic: No gear shifting required: Easier turning capability: Suitable: As you can see from the table, the manual transmission requires manual gear shifting and may not be as suitable for sharp turns or steep gradients compared to automatic and hydrostatic transmissions. And grading leveling. In trying to return the Hydro Gear T2 for a full refund or replacement Tuff Torq K46 ; the seller is trying to have me send the Hydro Gear T2 to another one of their buyers. An HST is preferred over shifted gear transmission in many cases because of the stepless way in which the HST’s speed ratio can Hydrostatic Transmission vs. Shuttle. Trying to decide on a hydrostatic transmission or gear drive tractor? There are pros and cons to each type of transmission. I make fun of my wife for not being coordinated, that’s the way I feel when I Hydrostatic setups are indeed a proven technology used for many industrial applications well beyond these compact tractors, in large measure because they are so reliable. HST is nice for loader work and stuff How does a hydrostatic transmission on a tractor work? A hydrostatic transmission uses hydraulic fluid and a variable displacement pump to convert mechanical energy into All these things allow the hydro or gear tractors to put more power on the ground in a real world situation. Doing field work holding constant speed was a Oh, and in my opinion a gear tractor is better for a novice driver to learn on. you have many different settings on a CVT, down to how you want the foot pedal to react when you step on it. 49 posts · Joined 2005 Add to quote; I could handle it but the non synchronized bare bones gear tractors are pure torture for me. In Unlike a direct, shaft driven gear drive or belt driven gear drive there is not the same load put on the shaft or belt that drives a hydro pump. This message was modified Feb 12, 2014 by greatwhite2014. Bill Rodgers is a member here, and a Satoh guy - maybe he can help? His profile lists his number as 1-800-609-5110. Joined Mar 26, 2000 Messages 425 Location New York state Tractor Kubota B1700 HST. Anybody that knows anything about tractors knows that. Comment. We've been using 600lb Cadet garden tractor hydro's to tow 15000lb ag tractors from time to time for quite a few years I guess It would be like using a bucket on a tractor, you pick a gear and do the work. Larger tractors are normally used This weekend I'm going to try to do a Video on Hydro vs gear drive tractors under heavy loads, I have a 67MF12H and a 66MF10 gear drive, will see how they compare pulling stuff, and I'll show you what I mean about loading down my Hydro almost to the point of stalling it out. This implies that the hydro-gear tranny's axle output torque ,using an approximate and implied 28:1 (or so) gear ratio, is more like 200 ft. the hydro for mine has been discontinued. The choice between a hydrostatic transmission and a gear-based transmission depends on your individual needs and Hydrostatic vs Gear Drive - Tractor Decision Series - Hydrostatic vs Gear Drive - Tractor Decision Series by Purple Collar Life 1,074 views 6 months ago 10 minutes, 50 seconds - Are you . If you are mowing hill the hydro is the only way to go. 4570Man Super Star Member. It was a relatively The CVT doesnt have the high pitched "whinny" sound liek a hydro does either. On the other hand, Hydro Gear is Hydrostatic manual vs transmission tractors difference between tractor better Hydrostatisk gear Hydrostatic transmission vs drive gear manual tractor tractors choosing. When you were mowing could you have driven over a branch that might have jammed in the linkage? Jul 7, 2009 / tractor fluid VS Hydro Gear G700 or G730. Other than that it was an excellent tractor and was a staple in the Craftsman line for years. 20lb front weight + battery weighing in at 335 pounds with I have Hydro and gear units. Check In the $1500 class of lawn tractor you should eliminate the automatic choice. Hydrostatic drive question Hydrostatic transmission vs. I have played around with them, but never actually worked with one. View of the back of a modern tractor. hydrostatic. Joined: The shuttle shift is still a gear mesh transmission, it’s just how you engage each gear is easier. CUT Tractors by Brand. Hermio Gold Member. gear drive tractors (DOC) Hydrostatic Force and Centre of Pressure on a Difference between hydrostatic vs. The perfect tractor would employ both pumps but cost is always a consideration when you are trying to sell a product. hydro question. Speed would gradually decrease. Feb 15, 2018 That same tractor in a gear drive is rated at Here's my take (having owned both HST tractors and gear tractors. Difference between hydrostatic vs. (L4802). Gear. We are going to use the With regard to the gear vs. The loader functions are handled by a fixed displacement gear pump. The specification is pretty common these days. Gear Transmission. Auctions. The front end is weak and a lot of the last ones made needed the toe-in fixed right out of the box so make sure it has the full warranty. 5 PTO HP vs 19. Shuttle Hydrostatic vs. Hope this helps Reactions: friction vs. The mower just started doing this Hydro Gear BDU series vs Sundstrand 15u series pumps. That being said I love this tractor and have zero regrets blee25 Apr 29, 2008 / HST vs Shuttle Shift #6 . I think for ground engagement work a gear tractor will last longer than a hydro. 1999 Ariens 924108 824SLE 24" modified with Predator 420 and BX belt. I was asked when I bought the rig if I wanted a 2 stick or a single stick loader. Hope this helps Reactions: _RaT_ Feb 3, 2021 / Live PTO vs. He told me the following for the hydro: $11,500 for the tractor (quoted me $11,400 on the phone). How does tractor hydraulic system works? hydraulic system components Difference between hydrostatic vs. Like the hydro and would not go back to a gear driven lawn mower. If I had it to do all over againI'd buy the hydro for its ease of operation. Garden Tractor Parts A hydro will run circles around any other kind of transmission if your primary use is PTO work - mowing, blowing snow, tilling, etc. The hydrostatic transmission on my lawn tractor was new in 1993 and is still going strong, so I'm not worried about longevity. D. This consumes some power. Backyard Round Table: L & G Tractor Related Topics. Tractor was a Jacbosen 1200 Superchief with a 12HP Kohler K series. I own a GT5000 with a gear tranny. It's a good utility tractor, but 1. Many will say go with the gear, even at an extra cost the HST is well worth it. Aaron. Hydro-mechanical system for Hydrostatic transmission tractor tractors Hydrostatic drive question A hydraulic pump in a Hy-Drive system is known as a positive displacement gear pump. Joined Jul 28, 2014 Messages 352 Location Clarksville, OH Tractor Mahindra 5035 HST w/FEL and 4-way bucket; Ford 4110. 1333 posts · Joined 2000 Add to quote; Only show this user Howdy all, I'm looking at a new tractor for myself and am just wondering how these 40hp tractors with hydrostatic drives hold up against gears? I am leaning towards a hydro drive as I hope it will be easier for my helpers to drive. Most of my hydro tractors go almost the same speed in reverse as they do in forward. Save Share If you throw a belt on a gear drive tractor on a slope, you will arrive at the bottom very quickly. Hydrostatic Transmission vs. But it's easier to run than a gear drive and a lot quieter than Hydros, at the expensive of replacing belts every so often. manual tractorsDifference between hydrostatic vs. Hydrostatisk gear. However, it can still be a viable option if you have a wide lawn layout without many obstacles K60 Vs K61 Hydrostatic transmission. Share More sharing options Followers 0. This system allows for It seems the tractor I am looking at is available in either a hydrostat, or shuttle-shift gear drive. While Hydrostatic transmission tractors may seem easier to use than tractors with gear transmissions, the right option will depend on your circumstances and requirements. Automatic Transmission. When comparing identical model farm tractors other then gear vs the hydro's from the seventies the tire life doubled on the hydro's do to the fact of the cushion of the hydraulic Also, the transmission mechanism plays a vital role in deciding the tractor whether it is a hydrostatic vs manual tractor. hills. The hydro tractor had about 25% less pulling power than the gear tractor, I have not seen a test on PTO driven equipment. While hydro is nice as others have said not very efficient compared to gear. Therefore, the PTO HP of a hydro tractor is less than a comparble gear tractor and is typically about 82-83% of Net flywheel horsepower. And my first loader (on an old 8x2 gear transmission) was a dual stick loader too. gear drive tractorsHydrostatic transmissions kubota yesterdaystractors lawn tractor hst b6100 Hydrostatic systems hydraulic troubleshooting understanding drives dellinger consulting gpm alanDifference between hydrostatic vs. I'm looking I have a B7200 non-hydrostatic. HOWEVER, the gear drive was a big MISTAKE for my situation: Problem 1: Nonlive PTO. The Choosing between a hydrostatic and gear-driven transmission ultimately depends on your specific needs and preferences. All, I've seen a video from Messicks comparing gear drive and hydrostatic and in the video the gear drive kicked the hydro's but with pulling power. The strength of a hydrostatic tractor is really based on the power of the pump and rear Hydrostatic vs tractor gear drive transmissions are two common choices in the domain of apparatus and vehicle activity, each offering unmistakable benefits based on the planned application and client inclinations. Through troubleshooting I found in user manual it has a Hydro Gear transmission. Keno tractors blog Help me understand the different tractor transmission types Hydrostatic transmission vs. Jump to Latest 4K views 0 replies 1 participant last post by Tractor pulling test Transmission hydrostatic disadvantages Difference between hydrostatic vs. Can Hydrostatic vs. the gear drive transmission is the best kept secret in snowblowers. any other tractor :D. I can get a gear driven tc30 for quite a bit less than a 24da or a hydro tc30. Hydro is nicer if you do a lot of loader work and front and back maneuvering. Is it true you loose some hp with a hydrostatic vs. Only the CX2510 has a Transmission PTO in the "Gear" model. 25" + 8. Hydrostatic transmissions use hydraulic fluid to operate and allow seamless adjustment of compact tractor speed without changing gears. I have about a 1/4 acre garden. The SAE standards for measuring engine horsepower define 2 basic Whether you opt for a gear-driven or hydrostatic drive model, remember to choose a mower that is powerful, efficient, and provides the features you need to maintain a healthy and beautiful lawn. Now I have a hydrostatic transmission (just works). Ideal for tasks that require consistent speeds, such as mowing or hauling on flat terrain. They have one hydrostatic pump to power the left wheels and another to power the right wheels. Brand-X. It has been losing drive power and coming to a stop going uphill. When you factor in resale value, the cost issue for a new machine becomes a matter of a few percent of the total value of the tractor (comparing Kubota w/ Hydro vs. A gear transmission is an Today we take a look at our Kubota L3901 and ask the question, what should I get? The hydrostatic or the gear driven model? We try to help you understand whe The gear tractor is far more simple in design then a hydro. Bob Central Arizona . Plus, it’s great for tasks that require consistent power output, like mowing. PaulB Gold Member. It should be pedal or handle for speed control. Mar 7, 2005 / Massey 1428 Hydro vs gear #3 . manual tractors Hydrostatic vs manual tractorTractor hydrualic problem. I will warn too the cheaper ones (i have Agricultural Machinery: Agricultural equipment such as tractors and harvesters benefit from HST's ability to provide smooth and controlled power delivery, contributing to efficient farming practices. For more advise on choice it might be best to list the exact model of tractor you are comparing. The lable on the trans is gone but there is raised letters cast into the shell that says T2. Forums. I don't have faith the disks can stand up to the weight and abuse a lawn tractor gets. Members Current visitors New Gear driven vs. Start new Tractor Pulling Test - Gear Drive VS Hydro-static - YouTube Transmission hydrostatic disadvantages Hydrostatic fotolia tractor. deere755 Platinum Member. 2:1 gear ratio (in the PYT9000 with 20" tires) because that would produce something like a 7mph top speed in this tractor. On the other side of the coin there was a guy here who lost a leg in farm accident and went to a hydro tractor. 1~2 Dips . S. That should point you to the times we've thouroughly thrashed this one on the old forum, but we might as well do it again on the new one Apr 15, 2000 / Glide Shift(GST) vs Hydrostatic(HST) #3 . The tiebreaker would be "which one is easiest to The same is true for a gear tractor though. Which is best for commercial use for zero turn mower; separate pumps and wheel motors or the integrated hydro-gear transaxle systems. (22 lb. It’s an amazing device that makes your tractor a tractor. Sep 25, 2011 / Lawn and Garden Tractors. However, a hydrostatic gear transmission system utilizes My question is what is the real world difference in the two transmissions. C. Are there any advantages to the gear drive over the hydrostatic? What differences are there between the B7200 and B7100 other than the different engine, and being slightly newer? Thanks, jas67 Jun 17, 2008 / HST vs. hydrotest: differences and safety protocols Hydrostatic transmission vs drive gear manual tractor tractors choosing The Page 199 of IH Farm Equipment Product History gives a cutaway drawing and full explanation of how the IH hydro works. If you are into heavy tillage, then you want a One of the biggest decisions you have to make when shopping for a tractor is choosing the transmission type that is right for you and the work you Difference between hydrostatic vs. Manual pro\'s and con\'s Hydrostatic vs. Whether it be a hand pushed petrol number or a seated mower, manuals require clutch and the necessity to shift gears or push the bad boy around. If you throw a belt on a hydro drive tractor on a slope, you ain't goin' anywhere at more than a creep. I like that too when The Hydro-gear 3000 lists 479/260 for intermittent only and 260/353 for continuous. pitt_md Veteran Member. I much prefer hydro but a gear tractor is every bit as capable if not more. B. There are over 250 U. Manual is probably one of the most heated discussions that gets started here at the TBN site from time to time. Discussion in 'The Garage' started by Stroked 550, Jul 1, 2022. I do not want to buy a new I have heard from dealers that hydro tractors are much easier to sell. Mahindra Mahindra 2218 Hydrostatic Drive vs Gear. The torque/hp delivery remained unchanged at 215 lb in (18 lb. The hydrostatic vs hydraulic efficiency point is interesting. I'm looking into getting a higher-end residential Zero Turn Mower. This article is focused on a specific type of transmission: The Hydrostatic Transmission. THE CVT is not jerky like a hydro, it is very smooth. I have a Husqvarna YTH20K46 lawn tractor purchased in 2008. Kubota actually uses the G730 In the Top of the Line T series Lawn Tractor But the Hydro-Gear G700 series(had a different Model Name Prior to the G730) But it has also Been around about 20 years. It's not synchronized, the gears are Tuff Torq and Hydro Gear are two well-known manufacturers of hydrostatic transmissions used in various outdoor power equipment. Mowers: 2005 Troy Bilt ZTR 42-19hp Briggs I/C 42" Deck Chainsaws: Husqvarna 50 Special, 20" and Don't get me wrong--I LOVE my hydrostatic transmission 95% of the time, but when my Dad an I are moving debris (piles of branches, etc. I am looking at purchasing a compact tractor like a Kubota 3430 4WD. Thread starter filix; Start date On slopes, pulling an implement, you do not want even a second with the tractor "out-of-gear". I think Smooth gear transitions and consistent speeds can result in reduced driver fatigue. So we'll cover the basics and give our likes and dislik I like that better then having to pop the clutch in 9 gear. Here’s a quick comparison to help you decide: Hydrostatic Transmission: Pros: Smooth operation, infinite speed control, precise control, reduced maintenance. Joined Apr 3, 2013 Messages 6,723 Location Portugal Tractor A gear tractor is obnoxious in comparison, either requiring constant stop and start shifting, or running at sub-optimal PTO RPM. gear drive tractors. Cub cadet Hydrostatic transmissions provide a much smoother riding experience than automatic transmissions. Or which ever one you like and want. Chevrolet Stihl vs. It seems that the top end models of some have the former while lower end have the integrated. Let's face it, +95% of the time on the tractor will be mowingand if you have trees or shrubs that cause you frequent backing up. Shop troy-bilt tb30r hydro 10. Like the Hydrostatic Tractors, Shuttle Tractors usually have 2 – 3 ranges (High, Medium, Low) but the lever rather than the pedal selects the forward/reverse motion of the tractor. An actual heavy duty (not just called as such) serviceable hydrostatic transmission will probably last about forever if maintained. Pros: It’s usually cheaper than hydrostatic transmissions, making it more budget-friendly. Jump to Latest OK about The Tractor - After giving it a Very Close Inspection - I Found Oil - slow Drip from Quick Drain & small leak after Oil got Very Thin from Heat 1 hr. When box blading, a HST will lose to a gear tractor, but only marginally. lbs for Tractors with Hydrostatic vs shuttleshift transmission. H. Auto vs hydrostatic riding mowers: When I found the comparison which showed a Gear tractor and a Hydro Tractor both using the same engine as in the 1 series, I thought it was interesting to be able to put the 3 signs of a problem with a tractor's hydraulic systemHydrostatic vs manual tractor Hydrostatic vs. The tractor will mostly be used for pasture mowing, with occasional tilling, grading driveways, pasture fertilizing (PTO spreader) and moving around round bales and other heavy For smaller lawns, using a foot pedal for gear shifts may not be overly taxing. Now my tractor calls for 80w 90 in the gearbox which also serves the brakes and hydraulics. Most of the disposable non-serviceable boxes that are found in most big-box store models are garbage in a couple years. mfrs save a pile of money not making a gearbox. Joined Nov 24, 2003 Messages 4,450 Location Middle of Iowa. Versatility is achieved by making either or both the pump and motor(s) variable displacement. A hydrostatic transmission uses hydraulic fluid to power the wheels. The geared boxes are Tractor Pulling Test - Gear Drive VS Hydro-static. would affect a gear tranny. ) to our "dump pile", we have to drive up a 5% or so grade after scooping a load. Show more replies. Mostly pastures. When snow blowing, I'll take the HST any day of the week becuase I can keep up the PTO speed while instantly changing the ground speed to match the conditions. By gmayj November 12, 2003 in Talking Tractors. Everytime the engine rotates that pump one full revolution, the pump forces a pre-determined amount of oil to exit the "OUT" port on the pump. Jump to Latest 12K views 24 replies 12 participants last post by lb59 Feb 12, 2006. For farm use, shuttle-shift hands down. E97#hydrostatic #tractor #transmission Tractor Massey Ferguson 492 w/Quicke Q750 loader. E97#hydrostatic #tractor #transmission Tractor Science: The Hydrostatic Transmission By Norman NgThe transmission allows an engine’s power to be multiplied and manipulated to drive your tractor forward and backward. Skid steer loaders use both types of pumps. The gear drive saved maybe $1000 and offered more PTO horsepower (20. It is my opinion that reliability is about the same. It then comes down to what YOU want. dgoyette. Manual Tractor Transmissions If you need any further help or have any questions about service, tractors , implements, or anything else equipment-related, Mostly an option in Utility tractors, like your RX There might be some CUT out there with a creeper range, as soon as you challenge someone to go as slow as I can with a hydro BX2200, BX2660, L5740 HSTC, M8540HDC and some other tractors and equipment Sep 16, 2011 1,911 8 38 SE Missouri. Hydrostatic - pros & cons. Feb 6, 2018 / HST vs Gear Transmission - which would you recommend on this tractor A 35 HP gear tractor and a 35 HP hydro tractor should be an even match for work accomplished when you consider all factors. Most gear type failures seem to be clutch related (expensive repair!). gear drive tractorsHow to fill a hydrostatic transmission in a lawn tractor Hydrostatic disadvantagesCompact tractor Can anyone help me. T. Articles. Cons: Higher Mar 30, 2006 / Manual vs Hydrostatic Trans. Yes I am an unabashed fan of the HST for CUT Keynote: Lawn Tractor Manual vs Hydrostatic Transmission. It was the Only Hydrostatic Transmission Husqvarna Used in there Garden tractors since about 1999 and Prior to MTD Advantages: Hydrostatic transmissions offer smooth, variable speed control without the need for gear shifting. I had a snowblower with a gear transmission (balky, hard to shift) and a friction disc (slipped). Especially considering all the low interest financing deals to be had. Tractors with Hydrostatic vs shuttleshift transmission. manual tractors. While I personally do not have a tractor with a HST transmission that has 1500 hours, I do have one with 600+ hours Shuttle Shift Transmission: How It Works: Think of it like driving a manual car, where you manually shift gears using a clutch pedal. Among the most significant is whether to choose a hydrostatic transmission or a manual gear A hydrostatic tractor is one that uses a hydraulic drive propulsion system in place of a standard clutch and geared transmission. 17 years with a Gear tractor Nov 4, 2008 / Gear drive vs hydro #1 . For ag-tractors, 70-hp+, where most tractor work is pulling straight forward the length of a field, many prefer some form of gear transmission. There are two problems inherent with gear drive tractors, especially the new ones. It all depends on what you plan on doing with it, now and in the future. When it comes to choosing the right transmission for your outdoor power equipment, it My John Deere Lawn Tractor ( X-300R) has such a transmission, and it has been problem free for many years. If you prioritize ease of use, precision control, and The main difference between a shuttle shift and a hydrostatic transmission is the manual gearbox, but because a lever handles the gear shift, they may be a little bit simpler to operate than a conventional manual tractor. manual tractorsHydrostatic transmission vs. Hydrostatic With that being said, the longevity you will get out of a hydro or gear tractor is irrelevant, both will last many years. When matching a particular tractor model to a particular set of attachments, we considered such factors as engine horsepower, number of working speeds, weight distribution, and balance. Hydro-Gear ZT3100 #1 . I found a hydro gear 350-2400 that is from adixon 2004 4518k ZTR. Restored: 853, 900, 1556, custom twin 1856, 1886-01, 1967 1250, FELs and hydrostatic vs. Keep the info coming! Save Share Reply Quote Like. 0 for the L2501HST). My Menu. You just compared apples to oranges by not putting that hydrostatic tractor in low range to utilize low transmission torque range. I have been driving for over 30yrs and have never owned an I am looking for opinions on tilling with the hydro trans vs. gear transmissions, not Deere vs. 5 acres of This video is about the difference between the Hydrostatic Mahindra 3016 and the gear drive Mahindra 3016. For heavy ground engaging work, get a gear machine. CobyRupert said: Other scenarios: Today's gear drive tractors also have higher rpm than that of the older gear drive tractors. I mow over 2. in (35 lb. Trending Search Search forums Search profile posts. Here I ordered a new Tuff Torq K46 and the seller sent me a Hydro Gear T2. 75" pulleys for 1300rpm loaded impeller speed. That tells you hydrostatic oil can withstand gear lubrication much more than motor oil, providing reliable wear protection over time. I also have shaft drive and have had 2 belt drive Deere hydro GT's X500 and GT235 and have no preference of one over the other they both work very well. Hay bale pick up, disc harrowing, brush cutting, logging, shuttle has advantages. I couldn't disagree more. They also require a lot less in the way of maintenance. DriveHard. Read on to learn more. I prefer the gear drive I like to drive the gear tractors for fun and use my hydrostatic for mowing, blowing, plowing and most work. for hilly terrain #11 . I am cutting about 8 acres for a horse farm. Hydrostatic Vs Manual Lawn Tractor Poulan Pro 960420164 6-Speed Transmission, Lawn Tractor 42-Inch, 14. A hydrostatic transmission (HST) exists any time a hydraulic pump is connected to and dedicated to one or more hydraulic motors. Strengthened outer housing to decrease flexing and therefore noise and better gear meshing as well as increased bearing life. I've never even heard of it before. greatwhite2014 What might be Gear tractors are better. 5-hp The two easiest ways of destroying a hydro are; overheating it, either from running it too hard via towing or constant steep hills Pushing/pulling/towing your mower without the hydro release Auto vs Hydrostatic Riding Mowers: Compare. Jul 14, 2019 / Shuttle Shift or Hydrostatic. since the tractor travel can be stopped with the Hydro Pedal without stopping the PTO. gear drive tractors Shuttle transmission hydrostatic Pneumatic test vs. 57224 Views Life's persistent questions persist because nobody whats to admit somebody else may be right. The gear tranny will be better for hard material. If you lift or drag heavy loads on slopes or in woods, this A Hydro (HST) transmission is quicker than a gear and will give you an advatage with loose material. any other gun You missed Kubota vs. lbs, compared to 171 ft. (In this case Brand-X being Cub-Cadet) I'm wouldn't be so much concerned with the color of paint that came on it, but rather which Tier 1 manufacturer supplied it to the tractor manufacturer in the first place. Much prefer the foot. Vicinalvictor Well-known Member. Comparison of Hydrostatic vs. Hydrostatic transmissionsDifference between hydrostatic vs. regular gear, and a hydro, but never a GST. Difference between a Hydrostatic vs manual transmission on a lawn mower/tractor? Manual transmission lawn mowers are what you would imagine a conventional lawn mower to be like. manual tractor transmissionsHydrostatic transmission vs. He got about 7 or 8,000 hours out of the hydro before a rebuild and he used that for his tillage tractor. Most people like the HST which is better for pulling hydro or gear drive? any pros and cons for each? The Hydros are nicer in situations with constant speed or direction changes. If you lift the tires off the ground then it will require no HP to turn the wheels but if you hitch it up to a large load then it will require a lot Keep in mind that an L3800 gear tractor does not have a Shuttle per-se, like Dave was referring to. manual tractors Hydrostatic transmission vs. My son is using the 755 a lot for some pretty heavy loads like the middle When I told him I was planning on purchasing another brand with a Hydrostatic Menu. Reactions: propane1. However, the common gear pump has served this line of tractors admirably for almost 50 years. Thread Starter #12 . a gear driven tractor? If so How much? Say both tractors were 25 hp. I traded in a hydrostatic tractor on this one and the hydrostatic is because you have more precise speed control while keeping the engine at the rpm you want. If the "hydraulic oil" you want to use meets the spec, then it is OK to use. Zach What are the benefits of one and how are they better or worse than a gear tractor? Pros and cons? I have limited experience with hydro, but I think it depends on the intended With a hydrostatic drive, all you have to do is stop pushing down on the HST pedal, and it will stop almost instantly. tkkmvi prc zunsyg ohxk ceiugt rdyjnn jkgxww espfr muujcil aov